CZ Talk:Images/Archive 1: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
imported>Stephen Ewen (→Fair use category needed: My current thinking on the matter -- subject to change as things get hammered out!) |
imported>Stephen Ewen |
||
| Line 5: | Line 5: | ||
We need a "Fair use" category. I suggest we adopt the ''Chicago Manual of Style'' (15th ed 2003) guidelines in ch 4 section 4.74-4.84. Note that Wiki limits its usefulness by rejecting fair use images. They have an odd reason for doing this (to protect future for-profit repackagers who do not currently exist). Our goal should be to emulate the academic world fair use practices, which maximize the benefits to the republic of letters. | We need a "Fair use" category. I suggest we adopt the ''Chicago Manual of Style'' (15th ed 2003) guidelines in ch 4 section 4.74-4.84. Note that Wiki limits its usefulness by rejecting fair use images. They have an odd reason for doing this (to protect future for-profit repackagers who do not currently exist). Our goal should be to emulate the academic world fair use practices, which maximize the benefits to the republic of letters. | ||
:Thanks, Richard. Please do continue to voice helpful things concerning the direction CZ should take in this matter. My current thinking on the matter: 1) free licenses, first, of course, the freer the better; failing this 2) use by permission, even if copyright all rights reserved; failing this 3) fair use. I am thinking it is preferable for CZ to use "fair use" images instead by permission whenever possible, and let ''re-users'' deal with the fair use matter concerning those same images. All subject to change as things get hammered out! —–[[User:Stephen Ewen|Stephen Ewen]] 02:19, 16 April 2007 (CDT) | :Thanks, Richard. Please do continue to voice helpful things concerning the direction CZ should take in this matter. My own current thinking on the matter: 1) free licenses, first, of course, the freer the better; failing this 2) use by permission, even if copyright all rights reserved; failing this 3) fair use. I am thinking it is preferable for CZ to use "fair use" images instead by permission whenever possible, and let ''re-users'' deal with the fair use matter concerning those same images. All subject to change as things get actually hammered out! —–[[User:Stephen Ewen|Stephen Ewen]] 02:19, 16 April 2007 (CDT) | ||
== Note on copyright when uploading == | == Note on copyright when uploading == | ||
Revision as of 01:24, 16 April 2007
~
Fair use category needed
We need a "Fair use" category. I suggest we adopt the Chicago Manual of Style (15th ed 2003) guidelines in ch 4 section 4.74-4.84. Note that Wiki limits its usefulness by rejecting fair use images. They have an odd reason for doing this (to protect future for-profit repackagers who do not currently exist). Our goal should be to emulate the academic world fair use practices, which maximize the benefits to the republic of letters.
- Thanks, Richard. Please do continue to voice helpful things concerning the direction CZ should take in this matter. My own current thinking on the matter: 1) free licenses, first, of course, the freer the better; failing this 2) use by permission, even if copyright all rights reserved; failing this 3) fair use. I am thinking it is preferable for CZ to use "fair use" images instead by permission whenever possible, and let re-users deal with the fair use matter concerning those same images. All subject to change as things get actually hammered out! —–Stephen Ewen 02:19, 16 April 2007 (CDT)
Note on copyright when uploading
I suggest we should place a note on the copyright not only in this help page, but directly in the page that opens when one uploads the image. Something like a list of licenses, among which the contributor can choose, or just a copy of this help appearing in the "upload file" procedure. I would do it myself... but I don't know how!
--Nereo Preto 02:04, 16 April 2007 (CDT)
- Only techs can edit that. I had them edit it some weeks ago. See Special:Upload. —–Stephen Ewen 02:09, 16 April 2007 (CDT)