Frontier, American: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Richard Jensen
(import from Wiki (mostly by RJ))
 
imported>Richard Jensen
(cleanup; add new material)
Line 1: Line 1:
:''This article is about the political and geographic term. For all other terms, see [[Frontier (disambiguation)]]
In American history the '''frontier''' is the process of settlement of new lands in the West, and the impact on the frontiersmen and the nation at large. As pioneers moved west they changed their customs, behavior and values and became more "American"; [[Frederick Jackson Turner]] called this "the significance of the frontier," Turner argued in 1893, one change was that unlimited free land in the zone was available and thus offered the psychological sense of unlimited opportunity, which in turn had many consequences, such as optimism, future orientation, shedding of restraints due to land scarcity, and wastefulness of natural resources.
A '''frontier''' is a [[political]] and [[geographical]] term referring to areas near or beyond a [[boundary]], or of a different nature.


==United States==
Throughout American history, the expansion of settlement was largely from the east to the west, and thus the frontier is often identified with "the west."  In New England, it moved north, so that Maine and Vermont had frontier characteristics.  
[[Image:1800's Texas House.JPG|right|thumb|250px|A restored pioneer house at the [[National Ranching Heritage Center]] in [[Lubbock, Texas]].]]
 
In the [[United States]], the '''frontier''' was the term applied by scholars to the impact of the zone of unsettled land outside the region of existing settlements of Americans.  That is, as pioneers moved into the frontier zone they were changed significantly by the encounter. That is what [[Frederick Jackson Turner]] called "the significance of the frontier." For example, Turner argued in 1893, one change was that unlimited free land in the zone was available and thus offered the psychological sense of unlimited opportunity, which in turn had many consequences, such as optimism, future orientation, shedding of restraints due to land scarcity, and wastefulness of natural resources.
 
Throughout American history, the expansion of settlement was largely from the east to the west, and thus the frontier is often identified with "the west."  On the Pacific Coast, settlement moved eastward. In New England, it moved north.
 
'Frontier' was borrowed into English from French in the 15th century with the meaning "borderland," the region of a country that fronts on another country (see also [[marches]]). The use of frontier to mean "a region at the edge of a settled area" is a special North American development. (Compare the Australian "[[outback]]".) In the Turnerian sense, "frontier" was a technical term that was explicated by hundreds of scholars.


===Colonial frontier===
===Colonial frontier===
''See also: [[Colonial America]], [[British colonization of the Americas]], [[French colonization of the Americas]]''
''See also: [[Colonial America]]
 
In the earliest days of European settlement of the [[Atlantic Ocean|Atlantic]] coast, the frontier was essentially any part of the forested interior of the continent beyond the fringe of existing settlements along the coast and the great rivers, such as the [[Saint Lawrence River|St. Lawrence]],  [[Connecticut River|Connecticut]], [[Hudson River|Hudson]], [[Delaware River|Delaware]], [[Susquehanna River]] and [[James River (Virginia)|James]].
In the earliest days of European settlement of the Atlantic coast, the frontier was essentially any part of the forested interior of the continent beyond the fringe of existing settlements along the coast.  
 
English, French, Spanish and Dutch patterns of expansion and settlement were quite different. Only a few thousand French migrated to Canada; these habitants settled in villages along the St. Lawrence river, building communities that remained stable for long stretches; they did not leapfrog west the way the Americans did.  Although French fur traders ranged widely through the [[Great Lakes (North America)|Great Lakes]] and [[Mississippi River]] watershed, as far as the [[Rocky Mountains]], they did not usually settle down.  Actual French settlement in these areas was limited to a few very small villages on the lower Mississippi and in the [[Illinois Country]].<ref> Clarence Walworth Alvord, ''The Illinois Country 1673-1818'' (1918)</ref> Likewise, the Dutch set up fur trading posts in the Hudson river valley, followed by large grants of land to patroons who brought in tenant farmers who created compact, permanent villages.  They did not push westward. <ref> Arthur G. Adams, ''The Hudson Through the Years'' (1996);  Sung Bok Kim, ''Landlord and Tenant in Colonial New York: Manorial Society, 1664-1775'' (1987)</ref> 
 
In contrast, the English colonies generally pursued a more systematic policy of widespread settlement of the New World for cultivation and exploitation of the land, a practice that required the extension of European [[property rights]] to the new continent. The typical English settlements were quite compact and small--under a square mile. Conflict with the Native Americans arose out of political issues, viz. who would rule. Early frontier areas east of the [[Appalachian Mountains]] included the [[Connecticut River|Connecticut]] river valley.<ref> Allan Kulikoff, ''From British Peasants to Colonial American Farmers'' (2000)</ref>  The [[French and Indian Wars]] of the 1760s resulted in a complete victory for the British, who took over the [[French colonial territory]] west of the Appalachians to the [[Mississippi River]]. Americans began moving across the Appalachians into areas such the Ohio Country and the [[New River Valley]].
 
==Canadian frontier==
 
A [[Canada|Canadian]] frontier thesis was developed by Canadian historians [[Harold Adams Innis]] and [[J. M. S. Careless]]. They emphasized the relationship between the center and periphery. Katerberg argues that "in Canada the imagined West must be understood in relation to the mythic power of the North." [Katerberg 2003] In Innis's 1930 work ''The Fur Trade in Canada'', he expounded on what became known as the Laurentian thesis: that the most creative and major developments in Canadian history occurred in the metropolitan centers of central Canada and that the civilization of North America is the civilization of Europe. Innis considered place as critical in the development of the Canadian West and wrote of the importance of metropolitan areas, settlements, and indigenous people in the creation of markets. Turner and Innis continue to exert influence over the historiography of the American and Canadian Wests.  The Quebec frontier showed little of the individualism or democracy that Turner ascribed to the American zone to the south.  The Nova Scotia and Ontario frontiers were rather more democratic than the rest of Canada, but whether that was caused by the need to be self-reliant on the frontier itself or the presence of large numbers of American immigrants is debated.
 
The Canadian political thinker [[Charles Blattberg]] has argued that such events ought to be seen as part of a process in which Canadians advanced a "border"-- as distinct from a "frontier"--from east to west. According to Blattberg, a border assumes a significantly sharper contrast between the civilized and the uncivilized since, unlike with a frontier process, the civilizing force is not supposed to be shaped by that which it is civilizing. Blattberg criticizes both the frontier and border "civilizing" processes.
 
===Canadian Prairies===
The pattern of settlement of the Canadian prairies began in 1896, when the American prairie states had already achieved statehood. Pioneers then headed north to the "[[Last Best West]]." 
Before settlers began to arrive, the [[North West Mounted Police]] was dispatched to the region. When settlers began to arrive, a system of law and order was already in place and the Dakota lawlessness for which the American "Wild West" was famed did not occur in Canada. Before settlers arrived, the federal government also sent teams of negotiators to meet with the Native peoples of the region. In a series of treaties, the basis for peaceful relations was established and the long wars with the Natives that occurred in the United States largely did not spread to Canada.  Like their American counterparts, the Prairie provinces supported populist and democratic movements in the early 20th century. <ref>Laycock, David.  ''Populism and Democratic Thought in the Canadian Prairies, 1910 to 1945.'' 1990; Seymour Martin Lipset, ''Agrarian Socialism'' (1950). </ref>


==Asia==
English, French, Spanish and Dutch patterns of expansion and settlement were quite different. Only a few thousand French migrated to Canada; these habitants settled in villages along the St. Lawrence river, building communities that remained stable for long stretches; they did not leapfrog west the way the Americans did.  Although French fur traders ranged widely through the Great Lakes region they seldom settle down.<ref>French settlement in these areas was limited to a few very small villages such as Kaskaskia. Clarence Walworth Alvord, ''The Illinois Country 1673-1818'' (1918)</ref> Likewise, the Dutch set up fur trading posts in the Hudson river valley, followed by large grants of land to rich landowning patroons who brought in tenant farmers who created compact, permanent villages.  They did not push westward. <ref> Arthur G. Adams, ''The Hudson Through the Years'' (1996);  Sung Bok Kim, ''Landlord and Tenant in Colonial New York: Manorial Society, 1664-1775'' (1987)</ref> 


The [[North-West Frontier Province]] is one of the four provinces of [[Pakistan]].
In contrast, the English colonies generally pursued a more systematic policy of widespread settlement of the New World for cultivation and exploitation of the land, a practice that required the application of legal property rights to the new conditions.  The typical English settlements were quite compact and small--under a square mile. Conflict with the Native Americans arose out of political issues, viz. who would rule. Early frontier areas east of the Appalachian Mountains included the Connecticut River valley.<ref> Allan Kulikoff, ''From British Peasants to Colonial American Farmers'' (2000)</ref>  The [[French and Indian Wars]] of the 1760s resulted in a complete victory for the British, who took over the lands west to the Mississippi River. By the early 1770s Americans were moving across the Appalachians into [[Pittsburgh, History before 1800|western Pennsylvania]], Kentucky, Tennessee and Ohio.
==Early National Era, 1770s-1830s==
After the Revolutionary war ended (1781), the Americans in large numbers poured into the west.  In some areas they had to battle the Indian tribes.  No Indians lived in Kentucky but they sent raiding parties to stop the newcomers, like [[Abe Lincoln]]'s grandfather (who was scalped in 1786 near Louisville.) The [[War of 1812]] marked the final confrontation between major Indian forces trying to stop the advance, with British aid. American frontier militiamen under [[Andrew Jackson]] defeated the Creeks and opened the Southwest, while militia under [[William Henry Harrison]] defeated the Indian-British alliance at a battle in Canada. The death in battle of the Indian leader [[Tecumseh]] dissolved the coalition of hostile Indian tribes. In general the frontiersmen battled the Indians with little help from the U.S. Army or the federal government.  Indeed, the regular army set up a line of forts designed to keep the Indians and settlers apart.


==Europe==
As settlers poured in the new areas went through the territorial stage and became states, typically dropping the legalistic practices favored by eastern upper classes, and adopting more democracy and more egalitarianism.
In the [[European Union]], the '''frontier''' is a term used to describe the region beyond the expanding borders of the European Union. The European Union has designated the countries surrounding it as part of the [[European Neighbourhood]]. This is a region of primarily less-developed countries, many of which aspire to become part of the European Union itself. Current applicants include Turkey and Croatia. Ukraine has also set itself the primary task of eventually joining the Union, as have many small countries in the Balkans and South Caucasus. Romania and Bulgaria, joined the European Union in 2007. Proposals to admit Turkey have been debated but are now currently stalled, partly on the ground that; Turkey is beyond Europe's historic frontier and it is yet to comply with the 35 point policy areas set out by the EU. If all or most East European states become members, the '''frontier''' may be the boundaries with Russia and Turkey.
==Later frontier, 1830s-1890==
 
==Debate on Turner's interpretation==
==See also==
Kearns (1998) examines the environmentalism of William Cronon and Donald Worster, and the revisionist moralism of Richard White and Patricia Limerick, who reject Turner as too favorable toward white men.
* [[American Old West]]
* [[Cabin Rights]]
* [[Frontier Thesis]]


==References==
==References==
===US history===
===Bibliography===
* [http://xroads.virginia.edu/~HYPER/TURNER/ The Frontier In American History] by Frederick Jackson Turner
* Billington, Ray Allen. ''America's Frontier Heritage'' (1984), an analysis of the frontier experience from perspective of social sciences and historiography
* Billington, Ray Allen. ''America's Frontier Heritage'' (1984), an analysis of the frontier experience from perspective of social sciences and historiography
* Billington, Ray Allen. ''Westward Expansion: A History of the American Frontier'' (1952 and later editions), the most detailed textbook, with highly detailed annotated bibliographies
* Billington, Ray Allen. ''Westward Expansion: A History of the American Frontier'' (1952 and later editions), the most detailed textbook, with highly detailed annotated bibliographies
* Billington, Ray Allen. ''Land of Savagery / Land of Promise: The European Image of the American Frontier in the Nineteenth Century'' (1981)
* Billington, Ray Allen. ''Land of Savagery / Land of Promise: The European Image of the American Frontier in the Nineteenth Century'' (1981)
* Blattberg, Charles ''Shall We Dance? A Patriotic Politics for Canada'' (2003), ch. 3, a comparison of the Canadian 'border' with the American 'frontier'
* Hine, Robert V.  and John Mack Faragher. ''The American West: A New Interpretive History'' (2000), recent textbook
* Hine, Robert V.  and John Mack Faragher. ''The American West: A New Interpretive History'' (2000), recent textbook
* Gerry Kearns. "The Virtuous Circle of Facts and Values in the New Western History," ''Annals of the Association of American Geographers'' (1998) 88 (3), 377–409.
* Lamar, Howard R. ed. ''The New Encyclopedia of the American West'' (1998), 1000+ pages of articles by scholars  
* Lamar, Howard R. ed. ''The New Encyclopedia of the American West'' (1998), 1000+ pages of articles by scholars  
* Patricia Nelson Limerick. ''The Legacy of Conquest: The Unbroken Past of the American West'' (1987) influential attack on Turnerian models.
* Milner, Clyde A., II ed. ''Major Problems in the History of the American West'' 2nd ed (1997), primary sources and essays by scholars
* Milner, Clyde A., II ed. ''Major Problems in the History of the American West'' 2nd ed (1997), primary sources and essays by scholars
* Nichols, Roger L. ed. ''American Frontier and Western Issues: An Historiographical Review'' (1986) essays by 14 scholars  
* Nichols, Roger L. ed. ''American Frontier and Western Issues: An Historiographical Review'' (1986) essays by 14 scholars  
* Paxson, Frederic, ''History of the American Frontier, 1763-1893'' (1924)
* Paxson, Frederic, ''History of the American Frontier, 1763-1893'' (1924), old textbook by Pulitzer Prize winner
* Slotkin, Richard, ''Regeneration Through Violence: The Mythology of the American Frontier, 1600-1860'' (2000), University of Oklahoma Press
* Slotkin, Richard, ''Regeneration Through Violence: The Mythology of the American Frontier, 1600-1860'' (2000), University of Oklahoma Press
 
* Turner, Frederick Jackson[http://xroads.virginia.edu/~HYPER/TURNER/ "The Frontier In American History"] (1893)
===Canada===
* Blattberg, Charles ''Shall We Dance? A Patriotic Politics for Canada'' (2003), ch. 3, a comparison of the Canadian 'border' with the American 'frontier'
* Cavell, Janice. "The Second Frontier: the North in English-canadian Historical Writing." ''Canadian Historical Review'' 2002 83(3): 364-389. ISSN 0008-3755 Fulltext in Ebsco
* Clarke, John.  ''Land, Power, and Economics on the Frontier of Upper Canada.'' McGill-Queen's U. Press, 2001. 747 pp. 
* Colpitts, George''Game in the Garden: A Human History of Wildlife in Western Canada to 1940'' U. of British Columbia Press, 2002. 216 pp. 
* Forkey, Neil S.  ''Shaping the Upper Canadian Frontier: Environment, Society and Culture in the Trent Valley.'' U. of Calgary Press 2003. 164 pp. 
* Katerberg, William H. "A Northern Vision: Frontiers and the West in the Canadian and American Imagination."  ''American Review of Canadian Studies'' 2003 33(4): 543-563. ISSN 0272-2011 Fulltext online at Ebsco
* Mulvihill, Peter R.; Baker, Douglas C.; and Morrison, William R. "A Conceptual Framework for Environmental History in Canada's North." ''Environmental History'' 2001 6(4): 611-626. ISSN 1084-5453. Proposes a five-part conceptual framework for the study of environmental history in the Canadian North. The first element of the framework analyzes approaches to environmental history that are applicable to the Canadian North. The second element reviews historical forces, myths, and defining characteristics that pertain to the region. A third element of the framework tests the validity of Turner's Frontier Thesis and Creighton's Metropolitan Thesis when applied to northern Canada. The fourth element consists of an overview of major northern environmental trends. The final element consists of four interrelated themes that identify the environmental relationships between northern and southern Canada.


==External links==
==External links==
* [http://xroads.virginia.edu/~HYPER/TURNER/ Turner Thesis text]
* [http://xroads.virginia.edu/~HYPER/TURNER/ Turner Thesis text]
* [http://www.transhumanist.com/volume4/space.htm Transhumanist.com: Opening Space as a Frontier]
----------
----
<references/>
<references/>
 
----------
[[Category:Canadian-American relations]]
[[Category:History Workgroup]]
[[Category:History of United States expansionism]]
[[Category:CZ Live]]
 
[[de:Grenzland]]
[[fr:Mythe de la Frontière]]
[[ja:フロンティア]]
[[no:Grenseområdene]]
[[pt:Fronteira]]

Revision as of 08:16, 26 April 2007

In American history the frontier is the process of settlement of new lands in the West, and the impact on the frontiersmen and the nation at large. As pioneers moved west they changed their customs, behavior and values and became more "American"; Frederick Jackson Turner called this "the significance of the frontier," Turner argued in 1893, one change was that unlimited free land in the zone was available and thus offered the psychological sense of unlimited opportunity, which in turn had many consequences, such as optimism, future orientation, shedding of restraints due to land scarcity, and wastefulness of natural resources.

Throughout American history, the expansion of settlement was largely from the east to the west, and thus the frontier is often identified with "the west." In New England, it moved north, so that Maine and Vermont had frontier characteristics.

Colonial frontier

See also: Colonial America

In the earliest days of European settlement of the Atlantic coast, the frontier was essentially any part of the forested interior of the continent beyond the fringe of existing settlements along the coast.

English, French, Spanish and Dutch patterns of expansion and settlement were quite different. Only a few thousand French migrated to Canada; these habitants settled in villages along the St. Lawrence river, building communities that remained stable for long stretches; they did not leapfrog west the way the Americans did. Although French fur traders ranged widely through the Great Lakes region they seldom settle down.[1] Likewise, the Dutch set up fur trading posts in the Hudson river valley, followed by large grants of land to rich landowning patroons who brought in tenant farmers who created compact, permanent villages. They did not push westward. [2]

In contrast, the English colonies generally pursued a more systematic policy of widespread settlement of the New World for cultivation and exploitation of the land, a practice that required the application of legal property rights to the new conditions. The typical English settlements were quite compact and small--under a square mile. Conflict with the Native Americans arose out of political issues, viz. who would rule. Early frontier areas east of the Appalachian Mountains included the Connecticut River valley.[3] The French and Indian Wars of the 1760s resulted in a complete victory for the British, who took over the lands west to the Mississippi River. By the early 1770s Americans were moving across the Appalachians into western Pennsylvania, Kentucky, Tennessee and Ohio.

Early National Era, 1770s-1830s

After the Revolutionary war ended (1781), the Americans in large numbers poured into the west. In some areas they had to battle the Indian tribes. No Indians lived in Kentucky but they sent raiding parties to stop the newcomers, like Abe Lincoln's grandfather (who was scalped in 1786 near Louisville.) The War of 1812 marked the final confrontation between major Indian forces trying to stop the advance, with British aid. American frontier militiamen under Andrew Jackson defeated the Creeks and opened the Southwest, while militia under William Henry Harrison defeated the Indian-British alliance at a battle in Canada. The death in battle of the Indian leader Tecumseh dissolved the coalition of hostile Indian tribes. In general the frontiersmen battled the Indians with little help from the U.S. Army or the federal government. Indeed, the regular army set up a line of forts designed to keep the Indians and settlers apart.

As settlers poured in the new areas went through the territorial stage and became states, typically dropping the legalistic practices favored by eastern upper classes, and adopting more democracy and more egalitarianism.

Later frontier, 1830s-1890

Debate on Turner's interpretation

Kearns (1998) examines the environmentalism of William Cronon and Donald Worster, and the revisionist moralism of Richard White and Patricia Limerick, who reject Turner as too favorable toward white men.

References

Bibliography

  • Billington, Ray Allen. America's Frontier Heritage (1984), an analysis of the frontier experience from perspective of social sciences and historiography
  • Billington, Ray Allen. Westward Expansion: A History of the American Frontier (1952 and later editions), the most detailed textbook, with highly detailed annotated bibliographies
  • Billington, Ray Allen. Land of Savagery / Land of Promise: The European Image of the American Frontier in the Nineteenth Century (1981)
  • Hine, Robert V. and John Mack Faragher. The American West: A New Interpretive History (2000), recent textbook
  • Gerry Kearns. "The Virtuous Circle of Facts and Values in the New Western History," Annals of the Association of American Geographers (1998) 88 (3), 377–409.
  • Lamar, Howard R. ed. The New Encyclopedia of the American West (1998), 1000+ pages of articles by scholars
  • Patricia Nelson Limerick. The Legacy of Conquest: The Unbroken Past of the American West (1987) influential attack on Turnerian models.
  • Milner, Clyde A., II ed. Major Problems in the History of the American West 2nd ed (1997), primary sources and essays by scholars
  • Nichols, Roger L. ed. American Frontier and Western Issues: An Historiographical Review (1986) essays by 14 scholars
  • Paxson, Frederic, History of the American Frontier, 1763-1893 (1924), old textbook by Pulitzer Prize winner
  • Slotkin, Richard, Regeneration Through Violence: The Mythology of the American Frontier, 1600-1860 (2000), University of Oklahoma Press
  • Turner, Frederick Jackson. "The Frontier In American History" (1893)

External links


  1. French settlement in these areas was limited to a few very small villages such as Kaskaskia. Clarence Walworth Alvord, The Illinois Country 1673-1818 (1918)
  2. Arthur G. Adams, The Hudson Through the Years (1996); Sung Bok Kim, Landlord and Tenant in Colonial New York: Manorial Society, 1664-1775 (1987)
  3. Allan Kulikoff, From British Peasants to Colonial American Farmers (2000)