Idée fixe: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>John R. Brews
(origin of term in medicine)
mNo edit summary
 
(2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 68: Line 68:
::::--Abraham B. Yehoshua ''Mr. Mani''<ref name=Halkin/>
::::--Abraham B. Yehoshua ''Mr. Mani''<ref name=Halkin/>


and in the account of the war on terror by [[George W. Bush|George Bush]]'s counter-terrorism chief [[Richard A. Clarke]]:
and in the account of the war on terror by [[George W. Bush|George Bush]]'s counterterrorism chief [[Richard A. Clarke]]:
:Iraq was portrayed as the most dangerous thing in national security. It was an idée fixe, a rigid belief, received wisdom, a decision already made and one that no fact or event could derail.
:Iraq was portrayed as the most dangerous thing in national security. It was an idée fixe, a rigid belief, received wisdom, a decision already made and one that no fact or event could derail.
::::--Richard A Clarke ''Against All Enemies: Inside America's War on Terror''<ref name=Clarke/>
::::--Richard A Clarke ''Against All Enemies: Inside America's War on Terror''<ref name=Clarke/>
Line 193: Line 193:


<ref name=phrenologist>
<ref name=phrenologist>
"''Idée fixe'' was also originally a medical term, probably coined by the phrenologists Gall and Spurzheim in connection with Esquirol's delinieation of monomania; see thier ''Anatomie et physiologie du système nerveux en général et du cerveau en particulier'', Vol. 2 (Paris: F. Schoell, 1812), p. 192. It also was transferred to nonmedical culture, most notably by the composer Hector Berlioz..." Quotation is a footnote from {{cite book|title=Console and Classify: The French Psychiatric Profession in the Nineteenth Century |author=Jan Ellen Goldstein |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=WiqKcO5OawgC&pg=PA155 |pages=p. 155 |isbn=0226301613 |publisher=University of Chicago Press |year=2002}}
Quoting from {{cite book|title=Console and Classify: The French Psychiatric Profession in the Nineteenth Century |author=Jan Ellen Goldstein |url=http://books.google.com/books?id=WiqKcO5OawgC&pg=PA155 |pages=p. 155 |isbn=0226301613 |publisher=University of Chicago Press |year=2002}}
"''Idée fixe'' was also originally a medical term, probably coined by the phrenologists Gall and Spurzheim in connection with Esquirol's delineation of monomania; see their ''Anatomie et physiologie du système nerveux en général et du cerveau en particulier'', Vol. 2 (Paris: F. Schoell, 1812), p. 192. It also was transferred to nonmedical culture, most notably by the composer Hector Berlioz..." The term ''leitmotif'' refers to the same musical device as ''idée fixe''.
</ref>
</ref>


Line 255: Line 256:




}}
}}[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]

Latest revision as of 06:01, 31 August 2024

This article is developing and not approved.
 Main Article
 Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
https://en.citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=Id%C3%A9e_fixe&printable=yes
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

An idée fixe is a preoccupation of mind held so firmly as to resist any attempt to modify it, a fixation. The name originates from the French for "fixed idea". Although not used technically to denote a particular disorder in psychology, idée fixe is used often in the description of disorders, and is employed widely in literature and everyday English.

Today's usage

See also: Monomania

As an everyday term, idée fixe may indicate a mindset akin to prejudice or stereotyping:[1]

Here again cognitive psychologists have done miracles in disclosing the well-nigh unlimited capabilities and eagerness of human beings to ward off contradictions inter alia by closing their eyes to data that are at variance with their assumptions. ... people who accept the stereotype...are forever coming up with evidence to support their idée fixe and seem unable to notice any information which might disturb their belief.
-- H. S. Versnel, Inconsistencies in Greek and Roman Religion[2]

However, idée fixe has also a pathological dimension, denoting serious psychological issues, as in this account of Japanese culture for a popular audience:

Although her husband did not reproach her, she became like a woman possessed, continually begging for his forgiveness. This he readily gave, but her guilt — and his imagined umbrage — had become for her an idée fixe. Unable to stomach food, she went into a decline and died soon thereafter.
--Jack Seaward The Japanese[3]

The pathology is what is denoted in psychology and in the law, as in this technical article about anorexia nervosa:

The idée fixe — staying thin — becomes at its furthest extreme so powerful as to render any other ideas or life projects meaningless. ... "I felt all inner development was ceasing, that all becoming and growing were being choked, because a single idea was filling my entire soul"
--Susan Bordo Toward a new psychology of gender[4]

Idée fixe began as a parent category of obsession,[5] and as a preoccupation of mind the idée fixe resembles today's obsessive-compulsive disorder: although the afflicted person can think, reason and act like other people, they are unable to stop a particular train of thought or action.[6] However, in obsessive-compulsive disorder, the victim recognizes the absurdity of the obsession or compulsion, not necessarily the case with an idée fixe, which normally is a delusion.[7]

Today, the term idée fixe does not denote a specific disorder in psychology, and does not appear as a technical designation in the Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders.[8] Nonetheless, idée fixe is used still as a descriptive term,[9] and appears in dictionaries of psychology.[10]

Background

The term idée fixe was introduced as a medical term around 1812 in connection with monomania.[11] As originally employed in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries,[12][13] idée fixe was "a single pathology of the intellect", distinct from monomania, a broader term that included idée fixe, but also a wider range of range of pathologies that did not stem from "a single compelling idea or from an emotional excess".[14] A second difference is that the victim of idée fixe was understood to be unaware of the unreality of their frame of mind,[15] while the victim of monomania might be aware.

At that time, idée fixe was discussed as a form of neurosis or monomania.[16]:

The meaning of monomania in the technical medical sense in which it was first used, was very close to the popular meaning it would soon acquire. It denoted an idée fixe, a single pathological preoccupation in an otherwise sound mind.[17]

The idea of monomania was developed by Esquirol as a diagnostic category in his work Des Malades Mentales (1839) and related to the idée fixe by Griesinger (1845) who viewed "every single idée fixe [as] the expression of a deeply deranged psychic individuality and probably an indicator of an incipient form of mania".[13] The "pathologicalization" of political convictions was used to discredit political anarchists.[12] The further historical evolution of idée fixe was much entangled with the introduction of psychologists into legal matters such as the insanity defense, and is found in a number of texts.[6][17][18]

Legal implications

During the nineteenth century and early twentieth century, monomania appears in treatises on criminal law:[19]

Monomania is a state of madness, or derangement of the mind, with respect to one subject only. Homicidal mania is an insane impulse to kill; pyromania is an insane impulse to burn buildings; and kleptomania is an insane impulse to steal. A person, therefore, may be insane and irresponsible as to one subject and at the same time sane and responsible to others. He may be punished unless impelled to crime by his monomania. But many courts hold that monomania causing an irresistible impulse to crime is no defense when the offender knew the act was wrong.

The aberrations of pyromania and kleptomania still are recognized as impulse control disorders or conduct disorders, and the notion of irresistible impulse still plays a legal role in the insanity defense.

Possibly the best example of the role of idée fixe in an insanity defense today is its use in identifying the paranoid personality disorder.[9]

A frequent manifestation of ... paranoid personality is the presence of an overvalued idea ... a fixed idea (idée fixe) ... which might seem reasonable both to the patient and to other people. However, it comes to dominate completely the person's thinking and life. ... It is quite distinct phenomenologically from both delusion and obsessional idea.

The extreme case of paranoid psychosis " ... includes preoccupation with delusional beliefs; believing that people are talking about oneself; believing one is being persecuted or being conspired against; and believing that people or external forces control one's actions."[20]

The legal issues surrounding paranoia include judgment of competence to stand trial, conditions for involuntary hospitalization, involuntary medication, and a focus upon awareness or not of unreality at the moment when the defendant "snapped".[21]

In literature

Idée fixe occurs extensively in literature.[22] Perhaps the most famous example of an idée fixe is in Cervantes's (1547-1616) Don Quixote:[23]

Don Quixote reveals his kinship to the most commonly encountered of Cervantes's character types: the head-in-clouds fantasist, obsessed by his idée fixe.[24]

Molière (1622-1673) also used the idée fixe repeatedly:[25]

Molière's more celebrated comic characters, Arnolphe, Orgon, Alceste, Harpagon, Monsieur Jourdain, Argan: each of them displays to the very end the obsession or idée fixe which colors his outlook on life. It is a characteristic of Molière's heroes that they are never ‘converted’: in every case the dénouement, far from curing them of their folly, merely confirms them in it.

Although Melville's (1819-1891) Captain Ahab may come to mind as another famous example of idée fixe, and it is sometimes referred to this way,[22] more often Ahab's obsession is referred to as monomania (the more inclusive term), and Melville himself does that. It would seem from the description of Ahab's possession that idée fixe applies quite accurately, as the following description suggests:

"Not one jot of his great natural intellect had perished." ... "Yielding up all his thoughts and fancies to his one supreme purpose", Ahab has let his mind's guiding and directing power be usurped by the "sheer inveteracy" of a will driven by "one unachieved revengeful desire" (Quotes from Moby-Dick, pp. 990, 1007)
--Thomas Cooley The ivory leg in the ebony cabinet: madness, race, and gender in Victorian America[26]

However, what makes monomania the better term is that “Captain Ahab ... has an inkling of his true state of mind: ‘my means are sane, my motive and my object mad.’”[26]

The words idée fixe also occur explicitly: for example, in Arthur Conan Doyle's (1859-1930) Sherlock Holmes:

There is the condition which the modern French psychologists have called the 'idée fixe', which may be trifling in character, and accompanied by complete sanity in every other way. A man might form such an idée fixe... and under its influence be capable of any fantastic outrage.
--Arthur Conan Doyle The return of Sherlock Holmes[27]

and in Abraham B. Yehoshua's novel about the Mani family through six generations:

...I had begun to despair of his accursed idée fixe which devoured every other idée that it encountered...
--Abraham B. Yehoshua Mr. Mani[28]

and in the account of the war on terror by George Bush's counterterrorism chief Richard A. Clarke:

Iraq was portrayed as the most dangerous thing in national security. It was an idée fixe, a rigid belief, received wisdom, a decision already made and one that no fact or event could derail.
--Richard A Clarke Against All Enemies: Inside America's War on Terror[29]

References

  1. ↑ Glen Fisher (1997). Mindsets: the role of culture and perception in international relations, 2nd ed. Intercultural Press, p. 22. ISBN 1877864544. 
  2. ↑ HS Vernel (1998). Inconsistencies in Greek and Roman Religion: Ter Unus: Isis, Dionysos, Hermes, 2nd ed. Koninklÿke Brill, p. 7. ISBN 9004092668. 
  3. ↑ Jack Seward (1992). The Japanese: the often misunderstood, sometimes surprising, and always fascinating culture and lifestyles of Japan. McGraw-Hill Professional, p. 226. ISBN 0844283932. 
  4. ↑ Susan Bordo (1996). “Anorexia nervosa: psychopathology as the crystallization of culture”, Mary M. Gergen, Sara N. Davis: Toward a new psychology of gender. Routledge, p. 441. ISBN 041591308X. 
  5. ↑ G. E. Berrios (1996). “Note 63”, The history of mental symptoms: descriptive psychopathology since the nineteenth century. Cambridge University Press, p. 153. ISBN 0521437369. 
  6. ↑ 6.0 6.1 Lennard J. Davis (2008). Obsession: a history. University of Chicago Press, pp. 69 ff. ISBN 0226137821. 
  7. ↑ Ian Jakes (1996). “The distinction between obsessional and psychotic thinking”, Theoretical approaches to obsessive-compulsive disorder. Cambridge University Press, p. 6. ISBN 0521460581. 
  8. ↑ (2000) Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders: DSM-IV-TR, 4rth ed. American Psychiatric Society. ISBN 0890420254. 
  9. ↑ 9.0 9.1 Femi Oyebode (2008). “Paranoid personality disorder”, Sims' Symptoms in the mind: an introduction to descriptive psychopathology, Updated 4th ed. Saunders Ltd, p. 382. ISBN 0702028851. 
  10. ↑ For example, Raymond J. Corsini (2002). The dictionary of psychology. Psychology Press, p. 467. ISBN 1583913289. 
  11. ↑ Quoting from Jan Ellen Goldstein (2002). Console and Classify: The French Psychiatric Profession in the Nineteenth Century. University of Chicago Press, p. 155. ISBN 0226301613.  "Idée fixe was also originally a medical term, probably coined by the phrenologists Gall and Spurzheim in connection with Esquirol's delineation of monomania; see their Anatomie et physiologie du système nerveux en général et du cerveau en particulier, Vol. 2 (Paris: F. Schoell, 1812), p. 192. It also was transferred to nonmedical culture, most notably by the composer Hector Berlioz..." The term leitmotif refers to the same musical device as idée fixe.
  12. ↑ 12.0 12.1 Michael Clark, Catherine Crawford (1994). Legal medicine in history. Cambridge University Press, pp. 214 ff. ISBN 0521395143. 
  13. ↑ 13.0 13.1 Alan Felthous, Henning Sass (2008). International Handbook on Psychopathic Disorders and the Law. John Wiley & Sons, p. 11. ISBN 0470066385. 
  14. ↑ Ann-Louise Shapiro (1996). Breaking the codes: female criminality in fin-de-siècle Paris. Stanford University Press, p. 100. ISBN 0804726930. 
  15. ↑ Daniel Hack Tuke (1892). A Dictionary of psychological medicine: giving the definition, etymology and synonyms of the terms used in medical psychology with the symptoms, treatment, and pathology of insanity and the law of lunacy in Great Britain and Ireland, Volume 2. J. & A. Churchill, p. 678. “Some of the French alienists extend the use of the term [imperative idea] to actual delusion (idée fixe ), as for instance, ideas of persecution. but it is to be hoped that [imperative idea] will be carefully restricted to that intellectual tyranny which the individual deplores and is not deluded by.” 
  16. ↑ F Raymond, Pierre Janet (1900). “Névroses et Idées Fixes”, Mind, Volume 9. Oxford University Press, pp. 94ff. 
  17. ↑ 17.0 17.1 Jan E. Goldstein (2002). Console and Classify: The French Psychiatric Profession in the Nineteenth Century. University of Chicago Press, p. 155. ISBN 0226301613. 
  18. ↑ Dorothea E. von Mücke (2003). The seduction of the occult and the rise of the fantastic tale. Stanford University Press, pp. 114 ff. ISBN 0804738602. 
  19. ↑ Thomas Welburn Hughes (1919). A treatise on criminal law and procedure. Bobbs-Merrill, p. 36. 
  20. ↑ Stephen M. Stahl (2008). “Psychosis and schizophrenia”, Stahl's essential psychopharmacology: Neuroscientific basis and practical applications, 3rd ed. Cambridge University Press, p. 249. ISBN 0521857023. 
  21. ↑ Martin Kantor (2004). “Chapter 8: Forensic issues”, Understanding paranoia: a guide for professionals, families, and sufferers. Greenwood Publishing Group, pp. 91 ff. ISBN 0275981525. 
  22. ↑ 22.0 22.1 Marina Van Zuylen (2005). Monomania: the flight from everyday life in literature and art. Cornell University Press, pp. 10, 38, 64, 68 .... ISBN 0801442982. 
  23. ↑ John Farrell (2006). Paranoia and modernity: Cervantes to Rousseau. Cornell University Press, p. 48. ISBN 0801444101. 
  24. ↑ Anthony J. Close (1990). Miguel de Cervantes, Don Quixote. Cambridge University Press, p. 106. ISBN 0521313457. 
  25. ↑ William Driver Howarth (1982). Molière, a playwright and his audience. Cambridge University Press, p. 99. ISBN 0521286794. 
  26. ↑ 26.0 26.1 Thomas Cooley (2001). The ivory leg in the ebony cabinet: madness, race, and gender in Victorian America. University of Massachusetts Press, p. 42. ISBN 1558492844.  Page numbers refer to Herman Melville (1983). G Thomas Tanselle: Moby-Dick, or the Whale, Reprint of the 1851 Northwestern-Newberry ed. Library of America. ISBN 0940450097. 
  27. ↑ Sir Arthur Conan Doyle (2003). “The return of Sherlock Holmes”, Kyle Freeman: The complete Sherlock Holmes, Volume 1 Barnes & Noble Classics. Spark Educational Publishing, p. 128. ISBN 1593080409. 
  28. ↑ Abraham B. Yehoshua (1993). Mr. Mani, Hillel Halkin translation. Houghton Mifflin Harcourt, p. 338. ISBN 0156627698. 
  29. ↑ Richard A Clarke (2004). Against All Enemies: Inside America's War on Terror. Free Press, p. 265. ISBN 0743260457. 
Retrieved from "https://citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=Idée_fixe&oldid=975648"