Necessary and sufficient: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Peter Schmitt
(draft to be edited)
mNo edit summary
 
(22 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{subpages}}
{{subpages}} {{TOC|right}}
 
In [[mathematics]], the phrase that some condition is
"'''necessary and sufficient'''" for some other statement
is frequently used,
in particular, in the statement of theorems, when justifying a step in a proof,
or to introduce an alternative version for a definition.


In [[mathematics]], the phrase
In [[mathematics]], the phrase
Line 13: Line 7:
in the text of proofs when a step has to be justified,
in the text of proofs when a step has to be justified,
or when an alternative version for a definition is given.
or when an alternative version for a definition is given.
 
<br>
To say that a statement is "necessary and sufficient" to another statement
To say that a statement is "necessary and sufficient" to another statement
means that the statements are either both true or both false.
means that the statements are either both true or both false.


Another phrase with the same meaning is "[[if and only if]]"
Another phrase with the same meaning is "[[if and only if]]" (abbreviated to "iff").
<br>
In formulae "necessary and sufficient" is denoted by <math>\Leftrightarrow</math>.
 
There are also some special terms used to indicate the presence of a necessary and sufficient condition,
usually used for statements of special significance:
 
A '''criterion''' is a proposition
that expresses a necessary and sufficient condition for a statement to be true.
The term is mostly used in cases
where this condition is easier to check than the statement itself.
<br>
While &mdash; in the strict sense of the word &mdash;
the condition given in a criterion has to be necessary and sufficient,
the term is sometimes (mostly out of tradition)
also used for conditions which are only sufficient.
 
A '''characterization''' of a mathematical object, a class of objects, or a property,
is an alternative description equivalent to a previously given definition,
i.e., a necessary and sufficient condition.
This term is mainly used in cases
where the condition is mathematically interesting and provides new insight.
 
== Necessary and sufficient ==


A statement ''A'' is (a) necessary and sufficient (condition)
A statement ''A'' is  
A statement ''A'' is necessary and sufficient
: "a necessary and sufficient condition",
                  is a necessary and sufficient condition
or shorter,
: "necessary and sufficient"
for another statement ''B''
for another statement ''B''
if it is both a necessary condition and a sufficient condition for ''B'',
if it is both  
i.e., if the following two propositions both are true:
* a necessary condition
and  
* a sufficient condition  
for ''B''.


* ''A'' is (a) necessary (condition) for ''B'',
== Necessary ==


The statement
The statement
* ''A'' is a necessary condition for ''B'',
* ''A'' is a necessary condition for ''B''
        (or shorter: is necessary for) ''B'',
or shorter
* ''A'' is necessary for ''B''
means precisely the same as each of the following statements:
means precisely the same as each of the following statements:
*  ''B'' is false whenever ''A'' does not hold, or, equivalently.
*  ''B'' implies ''A''.
*  If ''A'' is false then ''B'' cannot be true
*  If ''A'' is false then ''B'' cannot be true
*  ''B'' is false whenever ''A'' does not hold
*  ''B'' implies ''A''
== Sufficient ==


* ''A'' is (a) sufficient (condition) for ''B'',
The statement
* ''A'' is a sufficient condition for
* ''A'' is a sufficient condition for ''B''
        (or shorter: is sufficient for) ''B'',
or shorter
* ''A'' is sufficient for ''B''
means precisely the same as each of the following statements:
means precisely the same as each of the following statements:
*  ''B'' holds whenever ''A'' is true.
*  ''A'' implies ''B''
*  ''B'' holds whenever ''A'' is true.
*  ''B'' holds whenever ''A'' is true
*  ''A'' implies ''B''.
 
== Examples ==
 
For a sequence of positive real numbers to [[limit of a sequence|converge]] against a real number
* it is necessary that the sequence is bounded,
* it is sufficient that the sequence is monotone decreasing,
* it is necessary and sufficient that it is a [[Cauchy sequence]].
 
The same statements are expressed by:
 
* For a sequence &nbsp; <math> (a_n), \ 0 \le a_n \in \mathbb R </math> &nbsp; the following is true:
: <math> (\exists a\in\mathbb R) \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \ \Rightarrow    \  (a_n) \ \text{is bounded}              </math>
: <math> (\exists a\in\mathbb R) \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \ \Leftarrow      \  (a_n) \ \text{is monotone decreasing} </math>
: <math> (\exists a\in\mathbb R) \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \ \Leftrightarrow \  (a_n) \ \text{is a Cauchy sequence}    </math>
 
=== Cauchy convergence criterion ===
 
A sequence (''a''<sub>''n''</sub>) of real numbers is convergent
if and only if
for all &epsilon; > 0 there is a number ''N'' such that
|''a''<sub>''n''</sub> &minus; ''a''<sub>''m''</sub>| < &epsilon;
for all ''n'',''m'' > ''N''.
 
=== Root test ===


== Example ==
A [[series (mathematics)|series]] &nbsp; <math> \sum a_n </math> &nbsp;
of (real or complex) numbers ''a''<sub>''n''</sub>
* is convergent if &nbsp; <math> \limsup_{n\to\infty} \sqrt[n]{|a_n|} <1 </math>, and
* is divergent if &nbsp; <math> \limsup_{n\to\infty} \sqrt[n]{|a_n|} >1 </math>.


For a sequence of positive real numbers to converge against a limit
This test is traditionally often referred to as a "criterion" even though
* it is necessary that the sequence is bounded
* it does not decide in the case where &nbsp; <math> \limsup_{n\to\infty} \sqrt[n]{|a_n|} =1 </math>,
* it is sufficient that the sequence is monotone decreasing
and therefore is not a true criterion.
* it is necessary and sufficient that it is a Cauchy sequence.


A sequence
=== Characterization of circles ===
<math> (a_n), \ 0 \le a_n \in textrm R </math>
<math> \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \Rightarrow a_n \ \text{bounded} </math>
<math> \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \Leftarrow a_n \ \text{monotone decreasing} </math>
<math> \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \Leftrightarrow a_n \ \text{is a Cauchy sequence} </math>


<math> \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \Rightarrow a_n < C \in \textrm R </math>
A [[circle (geometry)|circle]] (in the plane) &mdash; more precisely: an arc of a circle &mdash; is usually defined as
<math> \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \Leftarrow
* a curve such that its points all have the same distance from a given point.
                    (\exists C)(\forall n) a_n < C \in \textrm R </math>
An example of an  alternative characterization of these arcs is the following:
<math> \lim_{n\to\infty} a_n = a \Leftarrow
* Circles are the plane curves with non-zero constant [[curvature]].[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]
      (\forall \epsilon >0)(\exists N\in \textrm N)
</math>

Latest revision as of 11:01, 24 September 2024

This article is developed but not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable, developed Main Article is subject to a disclaimer.

In mathematics, the phrase "necessary and sufficient" is frequently used, for instance, in the formulation of theorems, in the text of proofs when a step has to be justified, or when an alternative version for a definition is given.
To say that a statement is "necessary and sufficient" to another statement means that the statements are either both true or both false.

Another phrase with the same meaning is "if and only if" (abbreviated to "iff").
In formulae "necessary and sufficient" is denoted by .

There are also some special terms used to indicate the presence of a necessary and sufficient condition, usually used for statements of special significance:

A criterion is a proposition that expresses a necessary and sufficient condition for a statement to be true. The term is mostly used in cases where this condition is easier to check than the statement itself.
While — in the strict sense of the word — the condition given in a criterion has to be necessary and sufficient, the term is sometimes (mostly out of tradition) also used for conditions which are only sufficient.

A characterization of a mathematical object, a class of objects, or a property, is an alternative description equivalent to a previously given definition, i.e., a necessary and sufficient condition. This term is mainly used in cases where the condition is mathematically interesting and provides new insight.

Necessary and sufficient

A statement A is

"a necessary and sufficient condition",

or shorter,

"necessary and sufficient"

for another statement B if it is both

  • a necessary condition

and

  • a sufficient condition

for B.

Necessary

The statement

  • A is a necessary condition for B

or shorter

  • A is necessary for B

means precisely the same as each of the following statements:

  • If A is false then B cannot be true
  • B is false whenever A does not hold
  • B implies A

Sufficient

The statement

  • A is a sufficient condition for B

or shorter

  • A is sufficient for B

means precisely the same as each of the following statements:

  • A implies B
  • B holds whenever A is true

Examples

For a sequence of positive real numbers to converge against a real number

  • it is necessary that the sequence is bounded,
  • it is sufficient that the sequence is monotone decreasing,
  • it is necessary and sufficient that it is a Cauchy sequence.

The same statements are expressed by:

  • For a sequence     the following is true:

Cauchy convergence criterion

A sequence (an) of real numbers is convergent if and only if for all ε > 0 there is a number N such that |anam| < ε for all n,m > N.

Root test

A series     of (real or complex) numbers an

  • is convergent if   , and
  • is divergent if   .

This test is traditionally often referred to as a "criterion" even though

  • it does not decide in the case where   ,

and therefore is not a true criterion.

Characterization of circles

A circle (in the plane) — more precisely: an arc of a circle — is usually defined as

  • a curve such that its points all have the same distance from a given point.

An example of an alternative characterization of these arcs is the following:

  • Circles are the plane curves with non-zero constant curvature.