Talk:History of pie: Difference between revisions
imported>Mary Ash (Talk page generated using Special:MetadataForm) |
imported>Sandy Harris (question the lede) |
||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{subpages}} | {{subpages}} | ||
== American? == | |||
The current first sentence is "Pie is thought to be American in origin, as in "American Pie" but in actuality pie has a long history dating back to England." This seems problematic to me, since it would never have occurred to me to imagine pie was "American in origin". Steak & kidney pie is a traditional British dish, various sorts of meat pie are an Aussie staple (I think occupying a central place in their non-fancy culinary tradition like hamburgers for the US), Quebec has tourtiere [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tourti%C3%A8re], and so on. | |||
Did the notion of sweet pies, rather than meat-based ones, originate in America perhaps? Certainly we have expressions like "American as apple pie", and some pies such as Pecan pie (yuummm!) are very likely American. [[User:Sandy Harris|Sandy Harris]] 04:02, 11 August 2011 (UTC) | |||
Revision as of 22:02, 10 August 2011
American?
The current first sentence is "Pie is thought to be American in origin, as in "American Pie" but in actuality pie has a long history dating back to England." This seems problematic to me, since it would never have occurred to me to imagine pie was "American in origin". Steak & kidney pie is a traditional British dish, various sorts of meat pie are an Aussie staple (I think occupying a central place in their non-fancy culinary tradition like hamburgers for the US), Quebec has tourtiere [1], and so on.
Did the notion of sweet pies, rather than meat-based ones, originate in America perhaps? Certainly we have expressions like "American as apple pie", and some pies such as Pecan pie (yuummm!) are very likely American. Sandy Harris 04:02, 11 August 2011 (UTC)