User:Ian Helmke/Sandbox: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Ian Helmke
mNo edit summary
imported>Ian Helmke
mNo edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
= Clustering Additions =
= Clustering Additions =


This is text I'd like to add to the [[machine learning]] page (pending heavy editing). This text would go underneath the "Issues in Training and Evaluation" section.
This is text I'd like to add to the [[machine learning]] page (pending
heavy editing). This text would go underneath the "Issues in Training
and Evaluation" section.


== Overfitting ==
== Overfitting ==


Overfitting occurs when a classifier trains so closely to model data
Overfitting occurs when a classifier trains so closely to model data
that it is not useful for classifying things outside of the
that it is not useful for classifying things outside of the model.  
model. The classifier is extremely accurate when classifying the
training data, but when the classifier is used to classify data
outside of the model, it will often classify data incorrectly.


This can sometimes occur because a classifier looks at irrelevant data
This can sometimes occur because a classifier looks at irrelevant data
Line 15: Line 14:
features seen less commonly in the training data, and if data given to
features seen less commonly in the training data, and if data given to
the classifier shares similar uncommon values, it is grouped
the classifier shares similar uncommon values, it is grouped
accordingly. This produces inaccurate results.
accordingly. As a result, the classifier is extremely accurate when classifying the
training data and appears to be useful, but when it is
used to organize data outside of the model, it becomes inaccurate.


Machine learning techniques can prevent overfitting to some extent by
Machine learning techniques can prevent overfitting to some extent by
penalizing overly complicated models. A simpler model is oftentimes
imposing a penalty upon itself for complicated models. A
more consistent with the data in question.
simpler model is oftentimes more consistent with the trends of the
data in question.


== Imbalance of Data ==
== Imbalance of Data ==
Line 33: Line 35:


One way to prevent this imbalance of data is to use a technique called
One way to prevent this imbalance of data is to use a technique called
active example selection. Active example selection builds the
active example selection<ref>{{cite journal
      |author=Sangyoon, Oh et al.
      |title=Ensemble Learning with Active Example Selection for Imbalanced Biomedical Data Classification
      |journal=IEEE/ACM Trans. Comput. Biol. Bioinformatics
      |publisher=IEEE Computer Society Press
      |year=2011
      |id=http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TCBB.2010.96}}</ref>.
Active example selection builds the
classifier model slowly, adding a few pieces of sample data of each
classifier model slowly, adding a few pieces of sample data of each
class at a time. The model is tested at every stage, and documents
class at a time. The model is tested at every stage, and documents
Line 39: Line 48:
while ones that do not change the model or make its performance worse
while ones that do not change the model or make its performance worse
are removed. This ensures that only meaningful pieces of data are used
are removed. This ensures that only meaningful pieces of data are used
in the classifier.  
in the classifier.


== Evaluating Results ==
== Evaluating Results ==
Line 54: Line 63:
machine learning algorithm is compared to a set of data classified by
machine learning algorithm is compared to a set of data classified by
experts. In this case, the machine learning algorithm is given a set
experts. In this case, the machine learning algorithm is given a set
of training data, and then classifies a second sample set of data. A group of
of training data, and then classifies a second sample set of data. A
experts also annotate this second set of data, marking it according to how
group of experts also annotate this second set of data, marking it
they believe it should be classified (not according to how they
according to how they believe it should be classified (not according
believe a machine would classify it). This training and evaluation
to how they believe a machine would classify it). This training and
data is generally a tiny subset of the data available. If a classifier
evaluation data is generally a tiny subset of the data available. If a
is able to produce good results for a subset of data, it should also
classifier is able to produce good results for a subset of data, it
be successful at classifying a larger set of similar data.
should also be successful at classifying a larger set of similar data.
The results of the algorithm are compared to the results of the
The results of the algorithm are compared to the results of the
experts and arranged into two scores: precision and recall. Precision
experts and arranged into two scores: precision and recall. Precision
Line 83: Line 92:
the ability of an algorithm to be able to run in parallel and scale
the ability of an algorithm to be able to run in parallel and scale
accordingly (so that an algorithm running on two cores runs twice as
accordingly (so that an algorithm running on two cores runs twice as
fast, for example) allows it to
fast, for example) allows it to run faster on modern hardware, so that
run faster on modern hardware, so that larger quantities of data can
larger quantities of data can be processed.
be processed.


= Biclustering =
= Biclustering =


The following material would go on a new page of the above title (probably linked to the ML page)
''The following material would go on a new page of the above title
(probably linked to the ML page)''


'''Biclustering''' is an unsupervised [[machine learning]] method which searches
'''Biclustering''' is an unsupervised [[machine learning]] method
for similarities in specific subsections of the input data. It is unique among
which searches for similarities in specific subsections of the input
machine learning methods because it searches for similarities in small
data. It is unique among machine learning methods because it searches
parts of the data, instead of putting a piece of data into a single
for similarities in small parts of the data, instead of putting a
group.
piece of data into a single group.


Biclustering was first discovered in 1970. Today, it is a commonly
Biclustering was first discovered in 1970. Today, it is a commonly
Line 104: Line 113:
== Processing ==
== Processing ==


Clustering algorithms take [[vector|vectors]] as input. They sort the vectors
Clustering algorithms take [[vector|vectors]] as input. They sort the
according to how similar they are by comparing all of the features (data) in
vectors according to how similar they are by comparing all of the
the vector, and the result of the clustering is several groups that
features (data) in the vector, and the result of the clustering is
each contain a bunch of (hopefully) similar vectors. Biclustering
several groups that each contain a bunch of (hopefully) similar
looks at all of the vectors as a single input matrix, and attempts to
vectors. Biclustering looks at all of the vectors as a single input
find regions of the input which look similar.
matrix, and attempts to find regions of the input which look similar.


Biclustering is a useful technique for finding trends in data when
Biclustering is a useful technique for finding trends in data when
Line 122: Line 131:
Biclustering is particularly useful in the medical field, where it can
Biclustering is particularly useful in the medical field, where it can
be used, for example, to find genes related to a specific disease in a
be used, for example, to find genes related to a specific disease in a
group of patients. If each vector represents how a person expresses
group of patients<ref>{{cite journal
      |author=Still, Martin et al.
      |title=Robust biclustering by sparse singular value decomposition incorporating stability selection
      |publisher=Oxford University Press
      |journal=Bioinformatics
      |year=2011
      |id=http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btr322}}</ref>.
If each vector represents how a person expresses
traits, biclustering can be used to determine a set of genes which is
traits, biclustering can be used to determine a set of genes which is
associated with cancer. It can even be used to find similarities and
associated with cancer. It can even be used to find similarities and
differences between different varieties of cancers.
differences between different varieties of cancers.
== References ==
<references />

Revision as of 17:53, 1 August 2011

Clustering Additions

This is text I'd like to add to the machine learning page (pending heavy editing). This text would go underneath the "Issues in Training and Evaluation" section.

Overfitting

Overfitting occurs when a classifier trains so closely to model data that it is not useful for classifying things outside of the model.

This can sometimes occur because a classifier looks at irrelevant data points in the training data. Classifiers often give more weight to features seen less commonly in the training data, and if data given to the classifier shares similar uncommon values, it is grouped accordingly. As a result, the classifier is extremely accurate when classifying the training data and appears to be useful, but when it is used to organize data outside of the model, it becomes inaccurate.

Machine learning techniques can prevent overfitting to some extent by imposing a penalty upon itself for complicated models. A simpler model is oftentimes more consistent with the trends of the data in question.

Imbalance of Data

At times, data within training sets is imbalanced, where one sample category has many more points of data than another. Oftentimes, the category with less available data is the more interesting one, and we want to find characteristics that are common to the minority group that are also not shared by the majority group. Classifiers assume that the ratio of the different categories of training data that they receive are roughly equivalent to the ratio of real data that will belong in each category.

One way to prevent this imbalance of data is to use a technique called active example selection[1]. Active example selection builds the classifier model slowly, adding a few pieces of sample data of each class at a time. The model is tested at every stage, and documents which improve the accuracy of the model are kept in the classifier, while ones that do not change the model or make its performance worse are removed. This ensures that only meaningful pieces of data are used in the classifier.

Evaluating Results

There are a number of techniques for evaluating the results of a machine learning algorithm. Some of these techniques are also used in natural-language processing. Machine learning techniques are generally evaluated by their results, and some methods (such as neural networks) are considered "black box" forms of classification, since it is not easy to understand how or why the underlying implementation is sorting the way it is.

In some cases, particularly with classifiers, the outcome of the machine learning algorithm is compared to a set of data classified by experts. In this case, the machine learning algorithm is given a set of training data, and then classifies a second sample set of data. A group of experts also annotate this second set of data, marking it according to how they believe it should be classified (not according to how they believe a machine would classify it). This training and evaluation data is generally a tiny subset of the data available. If a classifier is able to produce good results for a subset of data, it should also be successful at classifying a larger set of similar data. The results of the algorithm are compared to the results of the experts and arranged into two scores: precision and recall. Precision accounts for situations where the classifier put something in a category where it did not belong. Recall accounts for situations where the classifier did not put something in a category it should have.

Classification and clustering algorithms can also be measured against other algorithms. This is useful when an algorithm is attempting to improve performance (speedwise, for example) while providing similar levels of precision and recall relative to another algorithm. It can also be used to show that an algorithm is an improvement over a previous generation, or to show which algorithm is most useful for organizing data for a particular problem.

Scalability

The ability of machine learning algorithms to take advantage of modern computers, which tend to have the ability to multitask exceptionally well through the use of multiple cores or CPUs, is important. Since these algorithms are often used to process large quantities of data, the ability of an algorithm to be able to run in parallel and scale accordingly (so that an algorithm running on two cores runs twice as fast, for example) allows it to run faster on modern hardware, so that larger quantities of data can be processed.

Biclustering

The following material would go on a new page of the above title (probably linked to the ML page)

Biclustering is an unsupervised machine learning method which searches for similarities in specific subsections of the input data. It is unique among machine learning methods because it searches for similarities in small parts of the data, instead of putting a piece of data into a single group.

Biclustering was first discovered in 1970. Today, it is a commonly used technique in bioinformatics, particularly in the area of gene expression, or identifying groups of genes that are similar between different people.

Processing

Clustering algorithms take vectors as input. They sort the vectors according to how similar they are by comparing all of the features (data) in the vector, and the result of the clustering is several groups that each contain a bunch of (hopefully) similar vectors. Biclustering looks at all of the vectors as a single input matrix, and attempts to find regions of the input which look similar.

Biclustering is a useful technique for finding trends in data when each vector of data is very large because it can spot trends in specific parts of data that clustering cannot. A normal clustering algorithm sorts pieces of data according to features that the majority of them share. Biclustering is able to organize data according to parts of them that seem similar.

Applications

Biclustering is particularly useful in the medical field, where it can be used, for example, to find genes related to a specific disease in a group of patients[2]. If each vector represents how a person expresses traits, biclustering can be used to determine a set of genes which is associated with cancer. It can even be used to find similarities and differences between different varieties of cancers.

References

  1. Sangyoon, Oh et al. (2011). "Ensemble Learning with Active Example Selection for Imbalanced Biomedical Data Classification". IEEE/ACM Trans. Comput. Biol. Bioinformatics. http://dx.doi.org/10.1109/TCBB.2010.96.
  2. Still, Martin et al. (2011). "Robust biclustering by sparse singular value decomposition incorporating stability selection". Bioinformatics. http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btr322.