Talk:Mother's Day U.S.: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
imported>Chunbum Park mNo edit summary |
imported>David Finn (reply to Derek) |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
:Derek I titled the article Mother's Day U.S. as it is an article about how the US celebrates its holiday. I know other countries celebrate Mother's Day but I chose to write about the US version. Feel free to write about other celebrations, if you like. [[User:Mary Ash|Mary Ash]] 22:06, 8 May 2011 (CDT) | :Derek I titled the article Mother's Day U.S. as it is an article about how the US celebrates its holiday. I know other countries celebrate Mother's Day but I chose to write about the US version. Feel free to write about other celebrations, if you like. [[User:Mary Ash|Mary Ash]] 22:06, 8 May 2011 (CDT) | ||
::I think the article's name should be "Mother's Day in the U.S." or "Mother's Day (U.S.)." ([[User:Chunbum Park|Chunbum Park]] 22:47, 8 May 2011 (CDT)) | ::I think the article's name should be "Mother's Day in the U.S." or "Mother's Day (U.S.)." ([[User:Chunbum Park|Chunbum Park]] 22:47, 8 May 2011 (CDT)) | ||
:Derek, you are quite right. | |||
:The question we should ask when starting ''any'' article is, is this article really necessary? | |||
:If we look at this article, we see it is called Mother's Day U.S., and we ask, what is so unique about the relationship between the U.S. and Mother's Day that it needs a separate article from [[Mother's Day]] itself? | |||
:Is CZ to have an article on [[Mother's Day U.K.]], and [[Moederdag N.L.]], and another article for every country? What is encyclopedically unique about Mother's Day U.S. as opposed to that in Britain or the Netherlands or any of the many other countries who celebrate the occasion? | |||
:The proof of the pudding is in the content - either this article is developed into an article unique from [[Mother's Day]] or this article will certainly end up as a section of [[Mother's Day]]. [[User:David Finn|David Finn]] 01:27, 9 May 2011 (CDT) | |||
Revision as of 00:27, 9 May 2011
I think my mother would like it pointed out that Mother's Day is celebrated elsewhere. (We had lunch, it was nice.) -Derek Hodges 19:40, 8 May 2011 (CDT)
- Derek I titled the article Mother's Day U.S. as it is an article about how the US celebrates its holiday. I know other countries celebrate Mother's Day but I chose to write about the US version. Feel free to write about other celebrations, if you like. Mary Ash 22:06, 8 May 2011 (CDT)
- I think the article's name should be "Mother's Day in the U.S." or "Mother's Day (U.S.)." (Chunbum Park 22:47, 8 May 2011 (CDT))
- Derek, you are quite right.
- The question we should ask when starting any article is, is this article really necessary?
- If we look at this article, we see it is called Mother's Day U.S., and we ask, what is so unique about the relationship between the U.S. and Mother's Day that it needs a separate article from Mother's Day itself?
- Is CZ to have an article on Mother's Day U.K., and Moederdag N.L., and another article for every country? What is encyclopedically unique about Mother's Day U.S. as opposed to that in Britain or the Netherlands or any of the many other countries who celebrate the occasion?
- The proof of the pudding is in the content - either this article is developed into an article unique from Mother's Day or this article will certainly end up as a section of Mother's Day. David Finn 01:27, 9 May 2011 (CDT)