Holocaust: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
imported>Howard C. Berkowitz
No edit summary
Line 14: Line 14:


The [[Nazis]] violently hated all the Jews and everything they stood for. They worked relentlessly toward the goal of removing all possible Jewish influences. Starting in the 1920s (when they were a small party) with a violently anti-Semitic rhetoric that blamed Jews for all the problems of Germany and the modern world, the Nazis defined Jews as a permanent “race” that would never change and could never be improved. The Nazis also strongly disliked Christianity as being too Jewish. Their goal was to return to a pre-Christian, all-Aryan (imaginary) world.  
The [[Nazis]] violently hated all the Jews and everything they stood for. They worked relentlessly toward the goal of removing all possible Jewish influences. Starting in the 1920s (when they were a small party) with a violently anti-Semitic rhetoric that blamed Jews for all the problems of Germany and the modern world, the Nazis defined Jews as a permanent “race” that would never change and could never be improved. The Nazis also strongly disliked Christianity as being too Jewish. Their goal was to return to a pre-Christian, all-Aryan (imaginary) world.  
==Leadership and goals==
Hitler was at the heart of the Holocaust.  While there is no confirmation, it is widely accepted that he gave the orders for the Final Solution verbally to Himmler and [[Hermann Goering]], Goering then being his deputy and economic chief.  Himmler then gave orders to [[Reinhard Heydrich]], who was doing detailed planning from 1939 onwards, culminating in the 1942 [[Wannsee Conference]].
There were two major factions in the SS, with different goals. The [[WVHA]] economic administration, under [[Oswald Pohl]], sought to maximize the gain from the camps, as with slave labor. Its [[Inspector of Concentration Camps]] actually ran them.
The other faction was the [[RSHA]] security administration, first under [[Reinhard Heydrich]] and then [[Ernst Kaltenbrunner]]. RSHA offices included the [[Gestapo]], whose Amt IVB, under [[Adolf Eichmann]] was the senior SS bureaucrat in charge of handling deportation and transportation to the camps. The [[RuSHA]], however, developed the racial policies and criteria for arrest.
==Timeline==
===Stage one: Persecution before Power===
The early Nazis, before coming to power in 1933, focused on Jews as the "other" and existential enemy.  [[Sturmabteilung]] (SA) "brownshirts" routinely harassed and attacked Jews, Communists, and others in the streets.
===Stage two: Emigration and sterilization===
===Stage two: Emigration and sterilization===
The second stage of Nazi policy concerning Jews, from 1933 to–1938, when Hitler was dictator in a peacetime Germany, involved the removal of Jews from all public office. The Nazis encouraged the Jews to leave and half of the Jewish population in Germany did so (including famous scientist [[Albert Einstein]] and the teenaged [[Henry Kissinger]]). The Nazis opened Dachau and other “concentration camps” to punish thousands of their political enemies—including many Jews. About 1,000 Jews were murdered in concentration camps inside Germany before 1939; these were distinct from the killing camps that were opened in 1942 in Poland.  
The second stage of Nazi policy concerning Jews, from 1933 to–1938, when Hitler was dictator in a peacetime Germany, involved the removal of Jews from all public office. The Nazis encouraged the Jews to leave and half of the Jewish population in Germany did so (including famous scientist [[Albert Einstein]] and the teenaged [[Henry Kissinger]]). The Nazis opened Dachau and other “concentration camps” to punish thousands of their political enemies—including many Jews. About 1,000 Jews were murdered in concentration camps inside Germany before 1939; these were distinct from the killing camps that were opened in 1942 in Poland.  
===Stage three: Forced relocation===
===Stage three: Forced relocation from Germany===
Stage three, from 1938–for 1941, involved increasingly severe and humiliating restrictions for Jews. “Kristallnacht” in November 1938 was a systematic violent attack on all synagogues. World public opinion grew hostile to the Nazi actions, who ; they responded by supporting pro-Nazi, anti-Semitic political movements in France and other countries, including the “German-American Bund.” After invading Poland in 1939, the Nazis forced two million Jews into a few ghettoes with below-starvation food allotments.  
Stage three, from 1938 to September 1939, involved increasingly severe and humiliating restrictions for Jews. “[[Kristallnacht]]” in November 1938 was a systematic violent attack on all synagogues. World public opinion grew hostile to the Nazi actions, who ; they responded by supporting pro-Nazi, anti-Semitic political movements in France and other countries, including the “German-American Bund.”  
===Stage 4: Active killing===
===Stage four: Relocation outside Germany===
Stage 4  began when the Germans invaded Russia in June 1941. [[Einsatzgruppen]]n of the SS not only massacred large numbers of Jews, but routinely included handicapped persons in open-air mass shootings.
After invading Poland in 1939, the Nazis forced two million Jews into a few ghettoes with below-starvation food allotments.  
===Stage 5: the Final Solution===
 
Stage 5 began at the [[Wannsee Conference]] in January 1942 began stage five of Nazi power; it was then that when top Nazis decided on a “Final Solution” —to round up and secretly execute all the Jews of Europe. Killing centers were opened in Poland, and thousands of trainloads of Jews were transported there. and Jews were gassed immediately upon arrival.cmc3 Over three million Jews (and numbers of gypsies and other hated groups) were murdered, mostly in 1942–43.
In rounding up Jews the Nazis sometimes had the enthusiastic cooperation of pro-Nazi governments (as in France and Slovakia). A few countries, including Italy and Hungary, tried to stall the Nazis, but the Germans took power directly and seized the Jews. Only Bulgaria and Denmark were largely successful in protecting their Jews.  
===Stage 6: Endgame===
Stage 6 arrived when the Soviet armies overran the Polish camps in 1944–45 and, liberated the survivors. In all, six million Jews were murdered; most of the 300,000 survivors emigrated to the United States or Israel.
==Victims==
Millions were victimized by the Nazi regime during the Holocaust. The Jews were always the principal targets; however, the Nazis also systematically hunted down and murdered the Roma people (“Gypsies”). They also targeted special enemies, including Communist activists, Jehovah’s Witnesses, homosexuals, and people with disabilities. The last group was the target of [[Nazi euthanasia programs|euthanasia]] programs carried out in German hospitals in 1939–1941., and These programs were stopped when German Christian leaders mobilized public opinion against them.
==Perpetrators==
Hitler was at the heart of the Holocaust.  While there is no confirmation, it is widely accepted that he gave the orders for the Final Solution verbally to Himmler and [[Hermann Goering]], Goering then being his deputy and economic chief.  Himmler then gave orders to [[Reinhard Heydrich]], who conducted the [[Wannsee Conference]].


There were two major factions in the SS, with different goals. The [[WVHA]] economic administration, under [[Oswald Pohl]], sought to maximize the gain from the camps, as with slave labor. Its [[Inspector of Concentration Camps]] actually ran them.
Planning for more drastic action had begun, although it was focused on mass emigration or relocation rather than physical destruction.  Goering wrote to Heydrich on 31 July 1941<blockquote>In completion of the task that that was entrusted to you in the edict dated January 24, 1939, I herewith charge you with making all the necessary preparations by means of emigration or evacuation in the most convenient way possible, given the present conditions. I herewith charge you with making all the necessary preparations with regard to the organizational, practical and financial aspects for an overall solution ''[[Gesamtloesung]]'' of the Jewish question in the German sphere of influence in Europe. Insofar as the competencies of other central organizations are affected, they are to cooperate with you. I further charge you with submitting to me promtly an overall plan of the preliminary organizational, practical and financial measures for the execution of the intended [[final solution]] ''[[Endloesung]]'' of the Jewish question.<ref name=YOE>{{citation
| author = Saul Friedlander | title = The Years of Extermination: Nazi Germany and the Jews, 1939-1945
| publisher = HarperCollins | year = 2007
}}, pp. 238-239</ref></blockquote>
===Stage five: Active killing===
Stage five began when the Germans invaded Russia in June 1941. [[Einsatzgruppen]]n of the SS not only massacred large numbers of Jews, but routinely included handicapped persons in open-air mass shootings.  
===Stage six: the Final Solution===
Stage 6 began at the [[Wannsee Conference]] in January 1942 began stage five of Nazi power; it was then that when top Nazis decided on a “Final Solution” —to round up and secretly execute all the Jews of Europe. Killing centers were opened in Poland, and thousands of trainloads of Jews were transported there. and Jews were gassed immediately upon arrival.cmc3 Over three million Jews (and numbers of gypsies and other hated groups) were murdered, mostly in 1942–43.
===Stage seven: Endgame===
Stage 7 arrived when the Soviet armies overran the Polish camps in 1944–45 and, liberated the survivors. In all, six million Jews were murdered; most of the 300,000 survivors emigrated to the United States or Israel.  


The other faction was the [[RSHA]] security administration, first under [[Reinhard Heydrich]] and the [[Ernst Kaltenbrunner]]. RSHA offices included the [[Gestapo]], whose Amt IVB, under [[Adolf Eichmann]] was the senior SS bureaucrat in charge of handling deportation and transportation to the camps. The [[RuSHA]], however, developed the racial policies and criteria for arrest.
==Defense==
==Collaborators==
===Resistance===
In rounding up Jews the Nazis sometimes had the enthusiastic cooperation of pro-Nazi governments (as in France and Slovakia). A few countries, including Italy and Hungary, tried to stall the Nazis, but the Germans took power directly and seized the Jews. Only Bulgaria and Denmark were largely successful in protecting their Jews.
==Bystanders==
In recent years much controversy has arisen over when President [[Franklin D. Roosevelt]] learned what about the Nazis, and what he did or did not do. Switzerland was neutral and accepted in some refugees, but it also made large profits by trading and banking with Germany;, and was in the 1990s the Swiss were forced in the 1990s  to make reparation payments.
==Interference==
===Resisters===
Resistance took many forms, from individual acts to hundreds of examples of organized, armed resistance. The most famous episode was the month-long uprising of 60,000 remaining Jews in the Warsaw Ghetto in April 1943. At the [[Sobibor Concentration Camp]], an uprising in October 1943 allowed 600 prisoners to escape.
Resistance took many forms, from individual acts to hundreds of examples of organized, armed resistance. The most famous episode was the month-long uprising of 60,000 remaining Jews in the Warsaw Ghetto in April 1943. At the [[Sobibor Concentration Camp]], an uprising in October 1943 allowed 600 prisoners to escape.
===Rescuers===
===Rescuers===
Rescuers hid potential victims as best they could; the tragic story of [[Anne Frank]] is the most famous. The Danish people managed to ferry their entire Jewish population to neutral Sweden in one night, under the noses of the Nazis. The pope helped protect some Italian Jews; it is still being debated whether or not he could have done much more. The most famous rescuer was [[Oskar Schindler]]; —“Schindler’s List” the movie is a tells the true story about of how he saved 1,100 Jews from the Nazis by setting up factories that produced defective munitions.<ref> [http://www.teachwithmovies.org/guides/schindlers-list.html Schindler's List] </ref>.  
Rescuers hid potential victims as best they could. The Danish people managed to ferry their entire Jewish population to neutral Sweden in one night, under the noses of the Nazis.  
===Survivors===
 
The survivors of the Final Solution were very quiet about their experiences until about 1961, when Adolf Eichmann was captured in South America by Israel, tried in Jerusalem, and executed. Since then the Holocaust has become recognized as the most horrible episode of the twentieth20th century, and it has been analyzed in numerous with many books, courses, museums, and movies. The most important museums are the Holocaust Museum in Washington, and the Museum of Tolerance in Los Angeles.
The [[Vatican and the Holocaust|role of the Vatican]] remains extremely complex.
===Liberators===
 
The Allies liberated the concentration camps in 1945, —but could they have the question remains whether they could have bombed the camps or otherwise stopped the Final Solution.?
The most famous German rescuer was [[Oskar Schindler]]; —“Schindler’s List” the movie is a tells the true story about of how he saved 1,100 Jews from the Nazis by setting up factories that produced defective munitions.<ref> [http://www.teachwithmovies.org/guides/schindlers-list.html Schindler's List] </ref>.  
 
===Liberation===
The Allies liberated the concentration camps in 1945. Questions have been asked if they could have done more to intervene.
====Intelligence====
First, the Allied high command did not necessarily realize the extent of the Holocaust or its facilities. For example, while there were photographs of the [[Auschwitz Concentration Camp]], they were not located and interpreted until 1970.  A photographic plane was photographing a I.G. Farben factory in the general area, and didn't turn off its camera until after it had passed over the Monowitz camp
<ref name=Brugioni-2004>{{cite web
  | title = Aerial Photographs of Auschwitz
  | work = The Auschwitz Album
  | publisher = Yad Vashem: The Holocaust Martyrs' and Heroes' Remembrance Authority
  | date = 2004
  | url = http://www1.yadvashem.org/exhibitions/album_auschwitz/air_photo/air_photographs.html
  | accessdate = 2007-09-16 }}</ref>. The factory was the main interest, and the WWII interpreters just marked Auschwitz as an unidentified installation. No one in that organization knew about human intelligence reports of the death camps, and only in the seventies did researchers learn the significance of the camp photographs.
<ref name=Brugioni-1983>{{cite journal
  | last = Brugioni
  | first = Dino
  | coauthors =
  | title = Auschwitz and Birkenau: Why the World War II Photo Interpreters Failed to Identify the Extermination Complex
  | journal =  Military Intelligence
  | volume = 9
  | issue = 1
  | pages = 50-55
  | date = Jan-Mar. 1983
  | url = http://www.globalsecurity.org/intell/library/imint/holocaust2.htm }}</ref>.
 
Brugioni explains why Allied intelligence knew little about the targets, even after the  President asked that the camps be bombed<ref name=Brugioni-1983 />. "When the bombing specialists were ordered to formulate plans for bombing the [[Auschwitz-Birkenau Concentration Camp|Auschwitz-Birkenau Extermination Complex]], officials of the Air Ministry, the Royal Air Force [[Bomber Command]] and the [[Eighth Air Force|U.S. 8th Air Force]] bemoaned the lack of aerial photographic coverage of the complex. In fact, such photos were readily available at the Allied Central Interpretation Unit at Royal Air Force Station Medmenham, 50 miles outside of London and at the Mediterranean Allied Photo Reconnaissance Wing in Italy. The ultimate irony was that no search for the aerial photos was ever instituted by either organization. In retrospect, it is a fact that by the time the Soviet Army reached Auschwitz on January 27, 1945, the Allies had photographed the Auschwitz-Birkenau Extermination Complex at least 30 times."
 
Refugee and underground [[human-source intelligence]] reports were not regarded as highly credible.
====Diversion from defeating Germany====
Second, there was a belief that defeating Germany in general was the best way to stop the killing.  The extermination camps in Poland were beyond the range of serious bombing missions from the Western Allies, unless the aircraft could refuel in Russia. Refueling rights were denied.
====Lack of sympathy====
Third, there may have been some degree of antisemitism that prevented it from being a high priority.  The Soviets were closer to the extermination camps, but antisemitism was Soviet policy.
==Trials==
==Trials==
The main war criminals were tried at the [[International Military Tribunal (Nuremberg)]] (IMT) in 1945–1947, and at smaller trials throughout Europe, especially the U.S. [[Nuremberg Military Tribunals]].
The main war criminals were tried at the [[International Military Tribunal (Nuremberg)]] (IMT) in 1945–1947, and at smaller trials throughout Europe, especially the U.S. [[Nuremberg Military Tribunals]].


==References==
==References==
{{reflist}}
{{reflist|2}}

Revision as of 02:27, 30 November 2010

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.

The Holocaust was the systematic killing of the Jews, and others deemed subhuman under the Nazi race and biological ideology of Europe by the Nazis. Shoah refers specifically to the killing of Jews, but the killing machinery was used extensively against Soviet prisoners of war, political opposition, Gypsies, Jehovah's Witnesses, etc.

Origins

See also: Nazi race and biological ideology

The ideological underpinnings of the annihilation of the handicapped, Jews and Gypsies as well as the mass killings of Slavic populations in German-occupied eastern Europe were based on widely accepted theories of the inequality of races. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen, in the controversial Hitler's Willing Executioners'', suggests that there is a long tradition of German antisemitism, something to which the current government is extremely careful to avoid. [1]

Eugenics, incorporating prescientific ideas of racial purity and purification had already existed long before the Nazis came to power.

The Nazis violently hated all the Jews and everything they stood for. They worked relentlessly toward the goal of removing all possible Jewish influences. Starting in the 1920s (when they were a small party) with a violently anti-Semitic rhetoric that blamed Jews for all the problems of Germany and the modern world, the Nazis defined Jews as a permanent “race” that would never change and could never be improved. The Nazis also strongly disliked Christianity as being too Jewish. Their goal was to return to a pre-Christian, all-Aryan (imaginary) world.

Leadership and goals

Hitler was at the heart of the Holocaust. While there is no confirmation, it is widely accepted that he gave the orders for the Final Solution verbally to Himmler and Hermann Goering, Goering then being his deputy and economic chief. Himmler then gave orders to Reinhard Heydrich, who was doing detailed planning from 1939 onwards, culminating in the 1942 Wannsee Conference.

There were two major factions in the SS, with different goals. The WVHA economic administration, under Oswald Pohl, sought to maximize the gain from the camps, as with slave labor. Its Inspector of Concentration Camps actually ran them.

The other faction was the RSHA security administration, first under Reinhard Heydrich and then Ernst Kaltenbrunner. RSHA offices included the Gestapo, whose Amt IVB, under Adolf Eichmann was the senior SS bureaucrat in charge of handling deportation and transportation to the camps. The RuSHA, however, developed the racial policies and criteria for arrest.

Timeline

Stage one: Persecution before Power

The early Nazis, before coming to power in 1933, focused on Jews as the "other" and existential enemy. Sturmabteilung (SA) "brownshirts" routinely harassed and attacked Jews, Communists, and others in the streets.

Stage two: Emigration and sterilization

The second stage of Nazi policy concerning Jews, from 1933 to–1938, when Hitler was dictator in a peacetime Germany, involved the removal of Jews from all public office. The Nazis encouraged the Jews to leave and half of the Jewish population in Germany did so (including famous scientist Albert Einstein and the teenaged Henry Kissinger). The Nazis opened Dachau and other “concentration camps” to punish thousands of their political enemies—including many Jews. About 1,000 Jews were murdered in concentration camps inside Germany before 1939; these were distinct from the killing camps that were opened in 1942 in Poland.

Stage three: Forced relocation from Germany

Stage three, from 1938 to September 1939, involved increasingly severe and humiliating restrictions for Jews. “Kristallnacht” in November 1938 was a systematic violent attack on all synagogues. World public opinion grew hostile to the Nazi actions, who ; they responded by supporting pro-Nazi, anti-Semitic political movements in France and other countries, including the “German-American Bund.”

Stage four: Relocation outside Germany

After invading Poland in 1939, the Nazis forced two million Jews into a few ghettoes with below-starvation food allotments.

In rounding up Jews the Nazis sometimes had the enthusiastic cooperation of pro-Nazi governments (as in France and Slovakia). A few countries, including Italy and Hungary, tried to stall the Nazis, but the Germans took power directly and seized the Jews. Only Bulgaria and Denmark were largely successful in protecting their Jews.

Planning for more drastic action had begun, although it was focused on mass emigration or relocation rather than physical destruction. Goering wrote to Heydrich on 31 July 1941

In completion of the task that that was entrusted to you in the edict dated January 24, 1939, I herewith charge you with making all the necessary preparations by means of emigration or evacuation in the most convenient way possible, given the present conditions. I herewith charge you with making all the necessary preparations with regard to the organizational, practical and financial aspects for an overall solution Gesamtloesung of the Jewish question in the German sphere of influence in Europe. Insofar as the competencies of other central organizations are affected, they are to cooperate with you. I further charge you with submitting to me promtly an overall plan of the preliminary organizational, practical and financial measures for the execution of the intended final solution Endloesung of the Jewish question.[2]

Stage five: Active killing

Stage five began when the Germans invaded Russia in June 1941. Einsatzgruppenn of the SS not only massacred large numbers of Jews, but routinely included handicapped persons in open-air mass shootings.

Stage six: the Final Solution

Stage 6 began at the Wannsee Conference in January 1942 began stage five of Nazi power; it was then that when top Nazis decided on a “Final Solution” —to round up and secretly execute all the Jews of Europe. Killing centers were opened in Poland, and thousands of trainloads of Jews were transported there. and Jews were gassed immediately upon arrival.cmc3 Over three million Jews (and numbers of gypsies and other hated groups) were murdered, mostly in 1942–43.

Stage seven: Endgame

Stage 7 arrived when the Soviet armies overran the Polish camps in 1944–45 and, liberated the survivors. In all, six million Jews were murdered; most of the 300,000 survivors emigrated to the United States or Israel.

Defense

Resistance

Resistance took many forms, from individual acts to hundreds of examples of organized, armed resistance. The most famous episode was the month-long uprising of 60,000 remaining Jews in the Warsaw Ghetto in April 1943. At the Sobibor Concentration Camp, an uprising in October 1943 allowed 600 prisoners to escape.

Rescuers

Rescuers hid potential victims as best they could. The Danish people managed to ferry their entire Jewish population to neutral Sweden in one night, under the noses of the Nazis.

The role of the Vatican remains extremely complex.

The most famous German rescuer was Oskar Schindler; —“Schindler’s List” the movie is a tells the true story about of how he saved 1,100 Jews from the Nazis by setting up factories that produced defective munitions.[3].

Liberation

The Allies liberated the concentration camps in 1945. Questions have been asked if they could have done more to intervene.

Intelligence

First, the Allied high command did not necessarily realize the extent of the Holocaust or its facilities. For example, while there were photographs of the Auschwitz Concentration Camp, they were not located and interpreted until 1970. A photographic plane was photographing a I.G. Farben factory in the general area, and didn't turn off its camera until after it had passed over the Monowitz camp [4]. The factory was the main interest, and the WWII interpreters just marked Auschwitz as an unidentified installation. No one in that organization knew about human intelligence reports of the death camps, and only in the seventies did researchers learn the significance of the camp photographs. [5].

Brugioni explains why Allied intelligence knew little about the targets, even after the President asked that the camps be bombed[5]. "When the bombing specialists were ordered to formulate plans for bombing the Auschwitz-Birkenau Extermination Complex, officials of the Air Ministry, the Royal Air Force Bomber Command and the U.S. 8th Air Force bemoaned the lack of aerial photographic coverage of the complex. In fact, such photos were readily available at the Allied Central Interpretation Unit at Royal Air Force Station Medmenham, 50 miles outside of London and at the Mediterranean Allied Photo Reconnaissance Wing in Italy. The ultimate irony was that no search for the aerial photos was ever instituted by either organization. In retrospect, it is a fact that by the time the Soviet Army reached Auschwitz on January 27, 1945, the Allies had photographed the Auschwitz-Birkenau Extermination Complex at least 30 times."

Refugee and underground human-source intelligence reports were not regarded as highly credible.

Diversion from defeating Germany

Second, there was a belief that defeating Germany in general was the best way to stop the killing. The extermination camps in Poland were beyond the range of serious bombing missions from the Western Allies, unless the aircraft could refuel in Russia. Refueling rights were denied.

Lack of sympathy

Third, there may have been some degree of antisemitism that prevented it from being a high priority. The Soviets were closer to the extermination camps, but antisemitism was Soviet policy.

Trials

The main war criminals were tried at the International Military Tribunal (Nuremberg) (IMT) in 1945–1947, and at smaller trials throughout Europe, especially the U.S. Nuremberg Military Tribunals.

References

  1. Daniel Jonah Goldhagen (1996), Hitler's Willing Executioners, Alfred A. Knopf, ISBN 9780679445958, p. 5
  2. Saul Friedlander (2007), The Years of Extermination: Nazi Germany and the Jews, 1939-1945, HarperCollins, pp. 238-239
  3. Schindler's List
  4. Aerial Photographs of Auschwitz. The Auschwitz Album. Yad Vashem: The Holocaust Martyrs' and Heroes' Remembrance Authority (2004). Retrieved on 2007-09-16.
  5. 5.0 5.1 Brugioni, Dino (Jan-Mar. 1983). "Auschwitz and Birkenau: Why the World War II Photo Interpreters Failed to Identify the Extermination Complex". Military Intelligence 9 (1): 50-55.