Dog breed: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Aleta Curry
(→‎Recognizing a new breed: cut sections to be moved)
mNo edit summary
 
(10 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
[[Image:NSRW Dogs 2.jpg|thumb|500px|right| Several of the older purebred dog breeds are illustrated in this engraving from the last century. 12 German Bulldog  13 Mastiff  14a Shorthaired  14b Long Haired St. Bernard  15 Newfoundland  16 Bull Terrior  17 English Bulldog  18 French Dwarf Bulldog  19 Pug Dog.]]
{{subpages}}
 
{{Image|NSRW Dogs 2.jpg|right|500px| Several of the older purebred dog breeds are illustrated in this engraving from the last century. 12 German Bulldog  13 Mastiff  14a Shorthaired  14b Long Haired St. Bernard  15 Newfoundland  16 Bull Terrior  17 English Bulldog  18 French Dwarf Bulldog  19 Pug Dog.}}
A '''dog breed''' is a group of [[dog]]s that share a set of very similar features, including a ''characteristic'' appearance and behavior.  The attributes that make a certain breed recognizeable ''as'' that breed are generally written into a formal "[[breed standard]]" by [[breed club]]s, although some dog organizations do not use formal standards.   
A '''dog breed''' is a group of [[dog]]s that share a set of very similar features, including a ''characteristic'' appearance and behavior.  The attributes that make a certain breed recognizeable ''as'' that breed are generally written into a formal "[[breed standard]]" by [[breed club]]s, although some dog organizations do not use formal standards.   


Line 13: Line 15:
It's easy to forget that until the industrial revolution brought us machines, animals were responsible for a great deal of labor.  The ''routine'' place of a dog among people in past eras was as some kind of worker. Almost all of the known breeds from ancient times were specialized for some sort of job.
It's easy to forget that until the industrial revolution brought us machines, animals were responsible for a great deal of labor.  The ''routine'' place of a dog among people in past eras was as some kind of worker. Almost all of the known breeds from ancient times were specialized for some sort of job.


"The archeologic record suggests that the first [[domestication|domestic dogs]] are found in the Middle East approximately 14,000 years ago".<ref>Robert K. Wayne, Elaine A. Ostrander: Origin, genetic diversity, and genome structure of the domestic dog BioEssays Volume 21, Issue 3, Date: March 1999, Pages: 247-257</ref>. There is every reason to believe that  [[selective breeding]] for specific characteristics has occured for thousands of years.  
"The archeologic record suggests that the first [[domestication|domestic dogs]] are found in the Middle East approximately 14,000 years ago".<ref>Robert K. Wayne, Elaine A. Ostrander: Origin, genetic diversity, and genome structure of the domestic dog BioEssays Volume 21, Issue 3, Date: March 1999, Pages: 247-257</ref>. There is every reason to believe that  [[selective breeding]] for specific characteristics has occurred for thousands of years.  
 
However long people have been breeding dogs, most of today's dog breeds have only been around for the last hundred years or so in their current forms.  In the 1870s, [[kennel club]]s were founded and kept records of breeds, setting breed standards and registering individual dogs. Those animals with credentials from the  [[registry (animal)|breed registries]] ("papers") are said to be "[[purebred]]".  In [[show dog]]s, only individuals whose mother and father are both registered members of the breed are able to be registered, and considered purebred. 
 
Breeders whose aim is to produce good working and field dogs, and those owners involved in disciplines involving working, hunting and trialling dogs, have traditionally been among the most vocal objectors to dog breeds maintained on the basis of looks alone.  Among the objections raised are:


However long people have been breeding dogs, most of today's dog breeds have only been around for the last hundred years or so in their current forms.  In the 1870s, [[kennel club]]s were founded and kept records of breeds, setting breed standards and registering individual dogs. Those animals with credentials from the [[registry (animal)|breed registries]] ("papers") are said to be "[[purebred]]".  In [[show dog]]s, only individuals whose mother and father are both registered members of the breed are able to be registered, and considered purebredThis concept has caused controversy both because of the difficulty of regulation and because of the possible genetic consequences of a limited population ([[inbreeding]]).  Recent work has been done to genetically classify the various breeds, with some surprising results regarding the estimated age and interrelations of the breeds.
*Continued inbreeding in a small population with no ''outcrosses'' concentrates genetic faults and leads to an unhealthy population
*In some instances the soundness of the breed has been questioned, as with [[brachycephalic dog|brachycephalic]] breeds and respiratory concerns
*Although kennel clubs regulate the issuance of dog pedigrees quite strictly, some people will always manipulate or cheat the system
*Breed clubs have lost control of the conformation of their dogs/the dog’s look has changed over time/the dog’s instincts have been changedPeople who feel this way are usually of the opinion that individuals in the show dog type of the particular breed can no longer work.
*Because all dogs are the same species, we cannot separate breeds of dogs by looks alone, but must consider the ability.  It should be noted, however, that in recent years scientists have been researching how to separate and classify dog breeds geneticallyIt may eventually be possible to determine that a dog is genetically a [[poodle]], for instance, by a blood or swab test.


==Recognizing a new breed==
==Recognizing a new breed==
One of the most contentious issues in [[dog breeding]] today is defining the point at which a distinct group of dogs becomes a breed.  Traditionally, this has been easier with dogs bred to purpose; later dogs were selected for appearance as well.  As dog breeds have become more refined, the point at which a new variety becomes a breed can be difficult to decide. National [[kennel clubs often differ in their recognition of breeds and rare breeds might not be recognised outside their home countries.  So a breed's status as being a "recognized" pure breed does not indicate how long it has been in existence as a distinct breed.  Usually, only dogs recognized by a kennel club are eligible to compete in that specific club's [[conformation show]]s and [[dog sports]], although many dog sports allow any healthy dog to compete regardless of the breed or registration.   
One of the most contentious issues in [[dog breeding]] today is defining the point at which a distinct group of dogs becomes a breed.  Traditionally, this has been easier with dogs bred to purpose; later, dogs were selected for appearance as well.  As dog breeds have become more refined, the point at which a new variety becomes a breed can be difficult to decide. National kennel clubs often differ in their recognition of breeds and rare breeds might not be recognised outside their home countries.  So a breed's status as being a "recognized" pure breed does not indicate how long it has been in existence as a distinct breed.  Usually, only dogs recognized by a kennel club are eligible to compete in that specific club's [[conformation show]]s and [[dog sports]], although many dog sports allow any healthy dog to compete regardless of the breed or registration.   
 
[[Image:Basenji2-at-DWP.jpg|thumbnail|left|250px|The Basenji is a distinctive African dog breed]]
Generally, before a type of dog is recognized as a breed, it must be shown that mating a pair of that type always produces dogs that have the same characteristics as the parents, usually both in appearance and in behavior. This is known as ''breeding true''.  There are many issues concerning what is considered breeding true. For example, [[Flat-Coated Retriever]]s must always be black; however, yellow coats occur occasionally in some litters, due to [[recessive gene]]s. Kennel clubs do not recognize the yellow dogs as legitimate members of the breed; some breeders will kill the puppies rather than risk having the dog grow up, breed, and produce more of the undesired yellow color, perpetuating the undesireable recessive gene; more often, today, such dogs are [[spaying and neutering|neutered]] and placed in homes as [[pet]]s.  As another example, a breeding pair of [[Belgian Shepherd]]s of the [[Belgian Shepherd Dog (Groenendael)|Groenendael]] variety can produce puppies of the [[Belgian Shepherd Dog (Tervueren)|Tervueren]] (brown) variety; the [[American Kennel Club|AKC]] considers the varieties to be totally different breeds and, therefore, the brown puppies are invalid and undesirable dogs, whereas the [[CKC]] considers them simply to be different color varieties of the same breed. 


Of course, everything that distinguishes one breed of dog from another does so in the minds of ''humans'', not dogs. Each named breed of dog fits some human image of a particular variety of canine. Despite that, not all dog breeds were bred by people. Some came about because a group of domestic dogs were isolated from other dogs by geographic barriers, and over the generations produced [[progeny]] that were all, or mostly, of a recognizeable type. These breeds, called [[natural breed]]s, often originated in mountainous areas or islands. If they had qualities that people found attractive or useful, such distinctive dogs were further bred by fanciers using [[artificial selection]] - that is, puppies were born to females whose mates were chosen by the breeders, rather than left up to the dogs. An example of a dog breed that is the result of both natural selection in an isolated area and selective breeding by dog fanciers is the [[Newfoundland dog|Newfoundland]].
<!--Can someone "caption" this photo? 
""-->
Everything that distinguishes one breed of dog from another does so in the minds of ''humans'', not dogs. Each named breed of dog fits a human image of a particular variety of canine. Generally, before a type of dog is recognized as a breed, it must be shown that mating a pair of that type always produces dogs that have the same characteristics as other individuals in the breed, rather than any of the component breeds, usually both in appearance and in behavior. This is known as ''breeding true'', a concept that is well-established, even if there are still some problems in its implementation. For example, even dogs with multi-generational pedigrees can occasionally "throw back" to an undesirable characteristic, due to [[recessive gene]]s.  There is also the problem of natural variants, as in coat colour and ear carriage. These are also controled by genes, and variations are natural.  How dog breed enthusiasts deal with such variations is by no means set in stone.  Whether puppies with a differing coat colour or pattern, for example, are considered bona fide members of the breed, members of a variant breed, members of a different breed or dogs with a disqualifying "fault", unacceptable for breeding, differs from club to club and country to country, and there is sometimes bitter acrimony.


:''See [[selective breeding]] for a detailed discussion on the process of developing, and defining animal breeds, and [[registry (animal)]] for a discussion of recording and maintaining breeds as well as ''open'' versus ''closed'' [[stud book]]s and some of the issues concerning purebreds.''
Not all dog breeds were created by people. Some came about because a group of domestic dogs were isolated from other dogs by geographic barriers, and over the generations produced [[progeny]] that were all, or mostly, of a recognizable type. These breeds, called [[natural breed]]s, often originated in mountainous areas or islands. If they had qualities that people found attractive or useful, such distinctive dogs were further bred by fanciers using [[artificial selection]] - that is, puppies were born to females whose mates were chosen by the breeders, rather than left up to the dogs. An example of a dog breed that is the result of both natural selection in an isolated area and selective breeding by dog fanciers is the [[Newfoundland dog|Newfoundland]].


[[Image:Basenji2-at-DWP.jpg|thumbnail|left|250px]]
:''See [[selective breeding]] for a detailed discussion on the process of developing and defining animal breeds, and [[registry (animal)]] for a discussion of recording and maintaining breeds as well as the concepts of ''stud books'' and ''[[papers]]''. Refer to [[dog group]] for a review of how dog breeds are organized.''


==References==
==References==
<div class="references-small" style="-moz-column-count:2; -webkit-column-count:2; column-count:2;">
<div class="references-small" style="-moz-column-count:2; -webkit-column-count:2; column-count:2;">
<references />
<references />
</div>
</div>[[Category:Suggestion Bot Tag]]
 
==Further reading==
*D. Caroline Coile Ph.D. : Encyclopedia of Dog Breeds . Second Edition.2005
 
==External links==
*[http://www.beautdogs.com/Sponenberg.htm Livestock Guard Dogs: What is a Breed and Why Does It Matter?]
*[http://www.akc.org/reg/dogreg_stats.cfm AKC Dog Registration Statistics for 2003 and 2004]
 
 
[[Category:Biology Workgroup]]
[[Category:Hobbies Workgroup]]
[[Category:CZ Live]]

Latest revision as of 06:00, 8 August 2024

This article is developing and not approved.
Main Article
Discussion
Related Articles  [?]
Bibliography  [?]
External Links  [?]
Citable Version  [?]
Catalogs [?]
 
This editable Main Article is under development and subject to a disclaimer.
Several of the older purebred dog breeds are illustrated in this engraving from the last century. 12 German Bulldog 13 Mastiff 14a Shorthaired 14b Long Haired St. Bernard 15 Newfoundland 16 Bull Terrior 17 English Bulldog 18 French Dwarf Bulldog 19 Pug Dog.

A dog breed is a group of dogs that share a set of very similar features, including a characteristic appearance and behavior. The attributes that make a certain breed recognizeable as that breed are generally written into a formal "breed standard" by breed clubs, although some dog organizations do not use formal standards.

Some breeds have been defined primarily by their ability to do a job, like hunt, herd - or fight. Whether or not the animal is currently used in its traditional role, a good specimen of the breed retains the characteristics that enable it to carry out that original purpose.

Other breeds are more strictly defined by their appearance. Appearance includes a wide range of details such as the shape and proportions of the muzzle, the color of the coat, and the set of the tail. These details are called conformation points; they describe how well the animal conforms to the written breed standard.

No matter how much the appearance of an animal differs from one dog breed to the next, all dogs are the same species, Canis familiaris. That means that all fertile dogs are capable of mating with each other and producing puppies. If a breed "breeds true", then the progeny of two parents of a single breed will produce pups that share the breed characteristics.

History of dog breeds

Long in the body and short in the leg, Dachshunds are a distinctive breed of hound dog.

It's easy to forget that until the industrial revolution brought us machines, animals were responsible for a great deal of labor. The routine place of a dog among people in past eras was as some kind of worker. Almost all of the known breeds from ancient times were specialized for some sort of job.

"The archeologic record suggests that the first domestic dogs are found in the Middle East approximately 14,000 years ago".[1]. There is every reason to believe that selective breeding for specific characteristics has occurred for thousands of years.

However long people have been breeding dogs, most of today's dog breeds have only been around for the last hundred years or so in their current forms. In the 1870s, kennel clubs were founded and kept records of breeds, setting breed standards and registering individual dogs. Those animals with credentials from the breed registries ("papers") are said to be "purebred". In show dogs, only individuals whose mother and father are both registered members of the breed are able to be registered, and considered purebred.

Breeders whose aim is to produce good working and field dogs, and those owners involved in disciplines involving working, hunting and trialling dogs, have traditionally been among the most vocal objectors to dog breeds maintained on the basis of looks alone. Among the objections raised are:

  • Continued inbreeding in a small population with no outcrosses concentrates genetic faults and leads to an unhealthy population
  • In some instances the soundness of the breed has been questioned, as with brachycephalic breeds and respiratory concerns
  • Although kennel clubs regulate the issuance of dog pedigrees quite strictly, some people will always manipulate or cheat the system
  • Breed clubs have lost control of the conformation of their dogs/the dog’s look has changed over time/the dog’s instincts have been changed. People who feel this way are usually of the opinion that individuals in the show dog type of the particular breed can no longer work.
  • Because all dogs are the same species, we cannot separate breeds of dogs by looks alone, but must consider the ability. It should be noted, however, that in recent years scientists have been researching how to separate and classify dog breeds genetically. It may eventually be possible to determine that a dog is genetically a poodle, for instance, by a blood or swab test.

Recognizing a new breed

One of the most contentious issues in dog breeding today is defining the point at which a distinct group of dogs becomes a breed. Traditionally, this has been easier with dogs bred to purpose; later, dogs were selected for appearance as well. As dog breeds have become more refined, the point at which a new variety becomes a breed can be difficult to decide. National kennel clubs often differ in their recognition of breeds and rare breeds might not be recognised outside their home countries. So a breed's status as being a "recognized" pure breed does not indicate how long it has been in existence as a distinct breed. Usually, only dogs recognized by a kennel club are eligible to compete in that specific club's conformation shows and dog sports, although many dog sports allow any healthy dog to compete regardless of the breed or registration.

The Basenji is a distinctive African dog breed

Everything that distinguishes one breed of dog from another does so in the minds of humans, not dogs. Each named breed of dog fits a human image of a particular variety of canine. Generally, before a type of dog is recognized as a breed, it must be shown that mating a pair of that type always produces dogs that have the same characteristics as other individuals in the breed, rather than any of the component breeds, usually both in appearance and in behavior. This is known as breeding true, a concept that is well-established, even if there are still some problems in its implementation. For example, even dogs with multi-generational pedigrees can occasionally "throw back" to an undesirable characteristic, due to recessive genes. There is also the problem of natural variants, as in coat colour and ear carriage. These are also controled by genes, and variations are natural. How dog breed enthusiasts deal with such variations is by no means set in stone. Whether puppies with a differing coat colour or pattern, for example, are considered bona fide members of the breed, members of a variant breed, members of a different breed or dogs with a disqualifying "fault", unacceptable for breeding, differs from club to club and country to country, and there is sometimes bitter acrimony.

Not all dog breeds were created by people. Some came about because a group of domestic dogs were isolated from other dogs by geographic barriers, and over the generations produced progeny that were all, or mostly, of a recognizable type. These breeds, called natural breeds, often originated in mountainous areas or islands. If they had qualities that people found attractive or useful, such distinctive dogs were further bred by fanciers using artificial selection - that is, puppies were born to females whose mates were chosen by the breeders, rather than left up to the dogs. An example of a dog breed that is the result of both natural selection in an isolated area and selective breeding by dog fanciers is the Newfoundland.

See selective breeding for a detailed discussion on the process of developing and defining animal breeds, and registry (animal) for a discussion of recording and maintaining breeds as well as the concepts of stud books and papers. Refer to dog group for a review of how dog breeds are organized.

References

  1. Robert K. Wayne, Elaine A. Ostrander: Origin, genetic diversity, and genome structure of the domestic dog BioEssays Volume 21, Issue 3, Date: March 1999, Pages: 247-257