The Al Qaida Plan (film): Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(add reference)
mNo edit summary
(10 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{PropDel}}<br><br>
{{subpages}}
{{subpages}}
'''The Al Qaida Plan''' is a 90 movie produced by self-described [[counter-terrorism]] expert [[Evan Kohlmann]].<ref name=McClatchy20080729>
'''The Al Qaida Plan''' is a 90 movie produced by self-described [[counter-terrorism]] expert Evan Kohlmann.<ref name=McClatchy2008-07-29/><ref name=AssociatedPress2008-07-28/><ref name=Nbc2008-07-28/><ref name=gulfnews2008-07-29/>
It was sponsored by the [[Office of Military Commissions]], to serve as evidence during the [[Guantanamo Military Commissions]].
According to [[Carol Rosenberg]] of the ''[[Miami Herald]]'':
{| class="wikitable"
|
:He modeled the video after The Nazi Plan, an instructional movie shown at the late 1940s Nuremberg tribunals for the most senior Nazi leadership.<ref name=gulfnews2008-07-29/>
|}
 
According to ''[[Reuters]]'' the [[Office of Military Commissions]] paid Kohlmann $20,000 to make the film.<ref name=reuters2008-07-28/>  It is 90 minutes long.
 
Initially [[Captain (USN)|Captain]] [[Keith Allred]], the [[President (Military Commission)|President]] of [[Salim Ahmed Hamdan]]'s Military Commission ruled that the film would be prejudicial, but he reversed this decision<ref name=AssociatedPress2008-07-28/>.  Defense counsel continued to object to its use.<ref name=nytimes2008-08-06/>
 
In an interview, in 2013, Kohlmann discussed criticism of his film.<ref name=theworld2013-08-14/>
 
Salim Hamdan, the first individual who had the video played to his jury, did plead guilty.<ref name=Doj2019-04-19/>  He later had his conviction overturned by the [[Court of Military Commission Review]].
 
==References==
{{reflist|refs=
<ref name=nytimes2008-08-06>
{{cite news   
| url        = https://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/06/washington/07gitmo.html?searchResultPosition=4
| title      = Bin Laden’s Former Driver Is Convicted in Split Verdict
| work        = [[New York Times]]
| author      = William Glaberson
| date        = 2008-08-06
| location    = [[Guantanamo Bay, Cuba]]
| archiveurl  =
| archivedate =
| accessdate  = 2024-05-21
| url-status  = live     
| quote      = Prosecutors, eager to shore up the image of the commissions here, presented a video that included graphic footage of Qaeda terror attacks and their victims.
}}
</ref>
 
<ref name=McClatchy2008-07-29>
{{cite news
{{cite news
| url=http://www.mcclatchydc.com/world/story/45762.html
| url=http://www.mcclatchydc.com/world/story/45762.html
Line 7: Line 42:
| author=[[Carol Rosenberg]]
| author=[[Carol Rosenberg]]
| date=2008-07-29
| date=2008-07-29
| archiveurl  =
| archivedate =
| url-status  = live
| accessdate=2008-07-28
| accessdate=2008-07-28
| quote=
| quote=
}} [http://www.webcitation.org/query?url=http%3A%2F%2Fwww.mcclatchydc.com%2Fworld%2Fstory%2F45762.html&date=2008-07-28 mirror]
}}
</ref><ref name=AssociatedPress20080728>
</ref>
 
<ref name=AssociatedPress2008-07-28>
{{cite news
{{cite news
| url=http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5hlkUMaokG6I7flYKGhlBfsW9qP9wD9273V4O0
| url=http://ap.google.com/article/ALeqM5hlkUMaokG6I7flYKGhlBfsW9qP9wD9273V4O0
Line 16: Line 56:
| publisher=[[Associated Press]]
| publisher=[[Associated Press]]
| date=2008-07-28
| date=2008-07-28
| archiveurl  =
| archivedate =
| url-status  = live
| accessdate=2008-07-28
| accessdate=2008-07-28
| quote=
| quote=
}} [http://www.webcitation.org/query?url=http%3A%2F%2Fap.google.com%2Farticle%2FALeqM5hlkUMaokG6I7flYKGhlBfsW9qP9wD9273V4O0&date=2008-07-28 mirror]
}}
</ref>   
</ref>   
It was sponsored by the [[Office of Military Commissions]], to serve as evidence during the [[Guantanamo Military Commissions]].
According to [[Carol Rosenberg]] of the ''[[Miami Herald]]'':
{{quotation|He modeled the video after The Nazi Plan, an instructional movie shown at the late 1940s Nuremberg tribunals for the most senior Nazi leadership.}}
Initially [[Captain (USN)|Captain]] [[Keith Allred]], the [[President (Military Commission)|President]] of [[Salim Ahmed Hamdan]]'s Military Commission ruled that the film would be prejudicial.<ref name=AssociatedPress20080728/>
But he reversed this decision.
==References==
<!--
| archivedate = | url-status = live | archiveurl = 
| url-status = live | archivedate = | archiveurl = 
| url-status = dead | archivedate = | archiveurl = 
-->
{{Reflist|refs=


<ref name=Nbc2008-07-28>
{{cite news       
{{cite news       
| url        =  
| url        = https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna25890459
| title      =  
| title      = Jurors at Gitmo terror trial see al-Qaida film
| work        =  
| work        = [[NBC News]]
| author      =  
| author      = 2008-07-28
| date        =  
| date        =  
| page        =  
| page        =  
| location    =  
| location    =  
| isbn        =
| language    =
| trans-title =
| archiveurl  =  
| archiveurl  =  
| archivedate =  
| archivedate =  
| accessdate  = 2023-10-11
| accessdate  = 2024-05-21
| url-status  = live
| url-status  = live
| quote      =  
| quote      =  
Line 54: Line 81:
</ref>
</ref>


<ref name=theworld2013-08-14>
{{cite news     
{{cite news     
| url        =  
| url        = https://theworld.org/stories/2013/08/14/terrorism-consultant-evan-kohlmann-criticized-over-al-qaida-plan-video
| title      =  
| title      = Terrorism consultant Evan Kohlmann criticized over ‘The al-Qaida Plan’ video
| work        =  
| work        = [[The World]]
| author      =  
| author      = Adaora Udoji, Dean Cappello, John Hockenberry
| date        =  
| date        = 2013-08-14
| page        =
| location    = 
| archiveurl  =
| archivedate =
| accessdate  = 2024-05-21
| url-status  = live     
| quote      =
}}
</ref>
 
<ref name=gulfnews2008-07-29>
{{cite news   
| url        = https://gulfnews.com/world/americas/guantanamo-trial-views-911-video-as-evidence-1.120890
| title      = Guantanamo trial views 9/11 video as 'evidence'
| work        = [[Gulf News]]
| date        = 2008-07-29
| page        =  
| page        =  
| location    =  
| location    =  
Line 65: Line 109:
| language    =  
| language    =  
| trans-title =  
| trans-title =  
| trans_title = 
| archiveurl  =  
| archiveurl  =  
| archivedate =  
| archivedate =  
| accessdate  = 2023-10-11
| accessdate  = 2024-05-21
| url-status  = live    
| url-status  = live
| quote      =  
| quote      =  
}}
}}
</ref>
</ref>


<ref name=Doj2019-04-19>
{{cite news     
{{cite news     
| url        =  
| url        = https://www.mc.mil/Portals/0/pdfs/KSM2/KSM%20II%20(AE617F(AAA)).pdf
| title      =  
| title      = UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. KHALID SHAIKH MOHAMMAD, WALID MUHAMMAD SALIH MUBARAK BIN ‘ATTASH, RAMZI BIN AL SHIBH, ALI ABDUL-AZIZ ALI, MUSTAFA AHMED ADAM AL HAWSAWI
| work        =  
| work        = [[Department of Justice]]
| author      =  
| author      =  
| date        =  
| date        = 2019-04-19
| page        =  
| page        =  
| location    =  
| location    =  
Line 84: Line 130:
| language    =  
| language    =  
| trans-title =  
| trans-title =  
| trans_title =
| archiveurl  =  
| archiveurl  =  
| archivedate =  
| archivedate =  
| accessdate  = 2023-10-11
| accessdate  = 2024-05-21
| url-status  = live
| url-status  = live
| quote      =  
| quote      =  
Line 104: Line 151:
| accessdate  = 2023-10-11
| accessdate  = 2023-10-11
| url-status  = live
| url-status  = live
| quote      = {{'}}The Al Qaida Plan{{'}} was made for $20,000 (10,000 pounds) by terrorism consultant Evan Kohlmann for the Office of Military Commissions, which is conducting the trials of terrorism suspects at Guantanamo. Its 90 minutes of video clips depict the history of al Qaeda from its formation in 1988 through the September 11 attacks.
| quote      = {{'}}The Al Qaida Plan{{'}} was made for $20,000 (10,000 pounds) by terrorism consultant Evan Kohlmann for the Office of Military Commissions, which is conducting the trials of terrorism suspects at Guantanamo. Its 90 minutes of video clips depict the history of Al-Qaeda from its formation in 1988 through the September 11 attacks.
}}
}}
</ref>
</ref>
}}
}}

Revision as of 14:29, 31 May 2024

This article may be deleted soon.
To oppose or discuss a nomination, please go to CZ:Proposed for deletion and follow the instructions.

For the monthly nomination lists, see Category:Articles for deletion.


The Al Qaida Plan is a 90 movie produced by self-described counter-terrorism expert Evan Kohlmann.[1][2][3][4] It was sponsored by the Office of Military Commissions, to serve as evidence during the Guantanamo Military Commissions. According to Carol Rosenberg of the Miami Herald:

He modeled the video after The Nazi Plan, an instructional movie shown at the late 1940s Nuremberg tribunals for the most senior Nazi leadership.[4]

According to Reuters the Office of Military Commissions paid Kohlmann $20,000 to make the film.[5] It is 90 minutes long.

Initially Captain Keith Allred, the President of Salim Ahmed Hamdan's Military Commission ruled that the film would be prejudicial, but he reversed this decision[2]. Defense counsel continued to object to its use.[6]

In an interview, in 2013, Kohlmann discussed criticism of his film.[7]

Salim Hamdan, the first individual who had the video played to his jury, did plead guilty.[8] He later had his conviction overturned by the Court of Military Commission Review.

References

  1. ↑ Carol Rosenberg. Lawyers give expert testimony at bin Laden's driver's trial, McClatchy News Service, 2008-07-29. Retrieved on 2008-07-28.
  2. ↑ 2.0 2.1 US-produced Al-Qaida movie played at Gitmo trial, Associated Press, 2008-07-28. Retrieved on 2008-07-28.
  3. ↑ 2008-07-28. Jurors at Gitmo terror trial see al-Qaida film, NBC News. Retrieved on 2024-05-21.
  4. ↑ 4.0 4.1 Guantanamo trial views 9/11 video as 'evidence', Gulf News, 2008-07-29. Retrieved on 2024-05-21.
  5. ↑ Randall Mikkelsen. Guantanamo trial views graphic September 11 video, Reuters, 2008-07-28. Retrieved on 2023-10-11. “'The Al Qaida Plan' was made for $20,000 (10,000 pounds) by terrorism consultant Evan Kohlmann for the Office of Military Commissions, which is conducting the trials of terrorism suspects at Guantanamo. Its 90 minutes of video clips depict the history of Al-Qaeda from its formation in 1988 through the September 11 attacks.”
  6. ↑ William Glaberson. Bin Laden’s Former Driver Is Convicted in Split Verdict, New York Times, 2008-08-06. Retrieved on 2024-05-21. “Prosecutors, eager to shore up the image of the commissions here, presented a video that included graphic footage of Qaeda terror attacks and their victims.”
  7. ↑ Adaora Udoji, Dean Cappello, John Hockenberry. Terrorism consultant Evan Kohlmann criticized over ‘The al-Qaida Plan’ video, The World, 2013-08-14. Retrieved on 2024-05-21.
  8. ↑ UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. KHALID SHAIKH MOHAMMAD, WALID MUHAMMAD SALIH MUBARAK BIN ‘ATTASH, RAMZI BIN AL SHIBH, ALI ABDUL-AZIZ ALI, MUSTAFA AHMED ADAM AL HAWSAWI, Department of Justice, 2019-04-19. Retrieved on 2024-05-21.
Retrieved from "https://citizendium.org/wiki/index.php?title=The_Al_Qaida_Plan_(film)&oldid=957192"