CZ:How did you hear about CZ?: Difference between revisions

From Citizendium
Jump to navigation Jump to search
imported>Stephen Ewen
imported>Todd Coles
(moved template)
 
(45 intermediate revisions by 10 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
This page is for the constabulary and personnel administrators to add entries to indicate how people heard about Citizendium. Tabulating this information helps "keep pulse" on how new entrants enter the community and can inform future recruitment efforts.  Just add your entry into one of the categories below. Create new categories as needed.
So how exactly ''did'' you first hear about Citizendium?


==Print publication==
Entries below come from two sources.
===News===
 
* "Motivated to sign up by a splenetic interview with Andrew Keen in the Sunday Times (London) saying that Wikipedia (which I use constantly and gratefully but carefully) is "full of mistakes, half-truths and misunderstandings". He had good words for Citizendium."
#'''The constabulary and personnel administrators'''.  As part of the application, people are asked to optionally respond to the question. These are added, omitting identifying details.
* "through Singapore newspapers who tout it as a better alternative to Wikipedia."
#'''YOU!'''  If you ''did not'' tell how you heard about CZ in your application, please do add the information below. ''Don't'' sign entries.
* Wall Street Journal "in an article discussing visitor-supported information internet sites".  
* "from Sunday Times (UK), 3 june 2007"
* "through a newspaper article which complained about the mediocrity that was tolerated in Wikipedia"


===Magazine===
Tabulating this information helps "keep pulse" on how new entrants enter the community and can inform future recruitment efforts.
* "A Brasilian magazine" (3X)
* PCMag (5X)
* "PC Pro magazine (UK) (2X)
* "the July 2007 issue of PC Authority magazine" (New Zealand)
* "in an article in the Chronicle of Higher Education".


===Other===
Just add your entry into one of the categories below. Create new categories as needed. 
* "through reading journal articles on wikis."


==Web==
==Web==
Line 28: Line 19:
* "through controversy deal with Wiki validity on a professional library/info science working group called LM_NET."
* "through controversy deal with Wiki validity on a professional library/info science working group called LM_NET."
* "in a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of Wikipedia on the ARNOVA-L discussion list."
* "in a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of Wikipedia on the ARNOVA-L discussion list."
* "through the ANE-2 elist"


===News===
===News===
* "from a Times Online article at http://technology.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/tech_and_web/personal_tech/article1874668.ece ".
* "from a Sunday Times Online (UK) article, [http://technology.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/tech_and_web/personal_tech/article1874668.ece 'Thinking is so over']".
* "via an online news article".
* "via an online news article".
* "while reading an article in US News and World Report digital magazine"
* "while reading an article in US News and World Report digital magazine"
* "from TechCrunch.com"
* "from TechCrunch.com"
* "While contributing to an article for NewAssignment.Net."
* "From a variety of sources, mostly through Yahoo! News."
*"I read two online articles in c/net News.com in March and April and bookmarked them without sending this registration material in, [http://news.com.com/Wikipedia+rival+makes+its+debut/2100-1025_3-6170405.html one] and [http://news.com.com/Wikipedia+today,+Citizendium+tomorrow/2008-1082_3-6173499.html two]."


===Podcast===
===Podcast===
Line 43: Line 38:
* "first through Mashable and then more through various Google searches".
* "first through Mashable and then more through various Google searches".
* "Google News Portuguese service"
* "Google News Portuguese service"
*"I stumbled on a Citizendium article while doing a Google search and liked what I saw."  [editor's note: this is exactly what we want to hear --LMS]
* "At a google wiki search"


===Website===
===Website===
* www.inq.com
* www.inq.com
* slashdot.org (3X)
* The Education Network[http://www.edna.edu.au/edna/go] Australia
* Conservapedia.com - the article on Larry Sanger
* [http://wikitruth.info Wikitruth]


===Wikipedia===
====Wikipedia====
* At Wikipedia, unspecified (3X)
* "At Wikipedia" - unspecified (4X)
* "The Citizendium or Sanger article"
* "The Citizendium or Sanger article". (2x)
* "from people bashing on Wikipedia"
* "from people bashing on Wikipedia".
* "At the Flagged Revisions project on WP, people kept invoking the CZ model."
* "At the Flagged Revisions project on WP, people kept invoking the CZ model."
* "through discussion with other Wikipedia editors
* "through discussion with other Wikipedia editors".
* "on the German Wikipedia site"
* "on the German Wikipedia site".
* "on the Wikipedia self article"
* "on the Wikipedia self article".
* "in an editorial on Wikipedia'.
 
==Print publication==
===Journal===
* "through reading journal articles on wikis."
* "in an article about Jimmy Wales in the June 2007 issue of Reason magazine".
*"the June 4th issue of Information Week."
 
===Magazine===
* PCMag (7X)
* Unspecified Brasilian magazine (3X)
* "PC Pro magazine (UK) (2X)
* "the July 2007 issue of PC Authority magazine" (New Zealand)
* "in an article in the Chronicle of Higher Education".
* "PC World review on Wikis"
*"the June 4th issue of Information Week."
*''[[New Scientist]]'' [http://www.newscientisttech.com/channel/tech/mg19225755.500-wikis-little-sister-hits-the-shelves.html magazine article], 31st October 2006 (2X)
 
===News===
* "Motivated to sign up by a splenetic interview with Andrew Keen in the Sunday Times (London) saying that Wikipedia (which I use constantly and gratefully but carefully) is 'full of mistakes, half-truths and misunderstandings. He had good words for Citizendium."
* "through Singapore newspapers who tout it as a better alternative to Wikipedia."
* Wall Street Journal "in an article discussing visitor-supported information internet sites".
* "from Sunday Times (UK), 3 june 2007"
* "through a newspaper article which complained about the mediocrity that was tolerated in Wikipedia"
* The Independent newspaper (UK)
* "reading in the news"
* Sydney Morning Herald (2X)


==Broadcast media==
==Broadcast media==
Line 60: Line 88:
* Monte Carlo FM Arabic Radio
* Monte Carlo FM Arabic Radio
*"on the radio program of R. U. Sirius in San Francisco via web link"
*"on the radio program of R. U. Sirius in San Francisco via web link"
* On the [[Ireland (state)|Irish]] radio station Today FM, which interviewd Larry.


==Recruited by a CZ contributor==
==Recruited by a CZ contributor==
* by a Citizendium contributor (4X)
===''After'' the Pilot===
* by a Citizendium contributor (6X)


==Word of mouth in meatspace==
===''Before'' the Pilot===
:''Does NOT include Eduzendium''


==Word-of-mouth in meatspace==
===Friend===
* "I first heard about Citizendium from a friend who felt very ill when he found that Wikipedia had a page on him."
* "I first heard about Citizendium from a friend who felt very ill when he found that Wikipedia had a page on him."
* "through a friend after we had done some research and were looking for a scholarly source similar to Wikipedia."
* "through a friend after we had done some research and were looking for a scholarly source similar to Wikipedia."
* "A fellow [national non-profit organization] employee"
* "I was referred to your site by someone else"
===School===
:''Does NOT include Eduzendium''
* "during a Geography lesson at [high] school"
* "during a Geography lesson at [high] school"


Line 76: Line 113:
* "a number of different places both in print media and online".
* "a number of different places both in print media and online".
* "through the media"
* "through the media"
* "in an editorial on Wikipedia"
* "I think I heard about Citizendium in the newspaper, but I think I rediscovered it whilst online."
* "I heard about Citizendium from a guest speaker on a meeting".
* "I have been made aware of the existence of this project during a lecture at my company."
{{constabulary}}

Latest revision as of 15:22, 26 January 2008

So how exactly did you first hear about Citizendium?

Entries below come from two sources.

  1. The constabulary and personnel administrators. As part of the application, people are asked to optionally respond to the question. These are added, omitting identifying details.
  2. YOU! If you did not tell how you heard about CZ in your application, please do add the information below. Don't sign entries.

Tabulating this information helps "keep pulse" on how new entrants enter the community and can inform future recruitment efforts.

Just add your entry into one of the categories below. Create new categories as needed.

Web

Blog

  • "on a blog"

List-serve

  • "It was mentioned on the email listserv for the Society of Personality & Social Psychology, as an alternative to Wikipedia."
  • "through the American Communication Association"
  • "through controversy deal with Wiki validity on a professional library/info science working group called LM_NET."
  • "in a discussion of the strengths and weaknesses of Wikipedia on the ARNOVA-L discussion list."
  • "through the ANE-2 elist"

News

  • "from a Sunday Times Online (UK) article, 'Thinking is so over'".
  • "via an online news article".
  • "while reading an article in US News and World Report digital magazine"
  • "from TechCrunch.com"
  • "While contributing to an article for NewAssignment.Net."
  • "From a variety of sources, mostly through Yahoo! News."
  • "I read two online articles in c/net News.com in March and April and bookmarked them without sending this registration material in, one and two."

Podcast

  • "Academic Impressions webinar by Ray Schroeder and Shari McCurdy"
  • "A variety of podcasts charting your progress this year"

Search engine

  • "at dmoz.org"
  • "first through Mashable and then more through various Google searches".
  • "Google News Portuguese service"
  • "I stumbled on a Citizendium article while doing a Google search and liked what I saw." [editor's note: this is exactly what we want to hear --LMS]
  • "At a google wiki search"

Website

  • www.inq.com
  • slashdot.org (3X)
  • The Education Network[1] Australia
  • Conservapedia.com - the article on Larry Sanger
  • Wikitruth

Wikipedia

  • "At Wikipedia" - unspecified (4X)
  • "The Citizendium or Sanger article". (2x)
  • "from people bashing on Wikipedia".
  • "At the Flagged Revisions project on WP, people kept invoking the CZ model."
  • "through discussion with other Wikipedia editors".
  • "on the German Wikipedia site".
  • "on the Wikipedia self article".
  • "in an editorial on Wikipedia'.

Print publication

Journal

  • "through reading journal articles on wikis."
  • "in an article about Jimmy Wales in the June 2007 issue of Reason magazine".
  • "the June 4th issue of Information Week."

Magazine

  • PCMag (7X)
  • Unspecified Brasilian magazine (3X)
  • "PC Pro magazine (UK) (2X)
  • "the July 2007 issue of PC Authority magazine" (New Zealand)
  • "in an article in the Chronicle of Higher Education".
  • "PC World review on Wikis"
  • "the June 4th issue of Information Week."
  • New Scientist magazine article, 31st October 2006 (2X)

News

  • "Motivated to sign up by a splenetic interview with Andrew Keen in the Sunday Times (London) saying that Wikipedia (which I use constantly and gratefully but carefully) is 'full of mistakes, half-truths and misunderstandings. He had good words for Citizendium."
  • "through Singapore newspapers who tout it as a better alternative to Wikipedia."
  • Wall Street Journal "in an article discussing visitor-supported information internet sites".
  • "from Sunday Times (UK), 3 june 2007"
  • "through a newspaper article which complained about the mediocrity that was tolerated in Wikipedia"
  • The Independent newspaper (UK)
  • "reading in the news"
  • Sydney Morning Herald (2X)

Broadcast media

Radio

  • Monte Carlo FM Arabic Radio
  • "on the radio program of R. U. Sirius in San Francisco via web link"
  • On the Irish radio station Today FM, which interviewd Larry.

Recruited by a CZ contributor

After the Pilot

  • by a Citizendium contributor (6X)

Before the Pilot

Word-of-mouth in meatspace

Friend

  • "I first heard about Citizendium from a friend who felt very ill when he found that Wikipedia had a page on him."
  • "through a friend after we had done some research and were looking for a scholarly source similar to Wikipedia."
  • "A fellow [national non-profit organization] employee"
  • "I was referred to your site by someone else"

School

Does NOT include Eduzendium
  • "during a Geography lesson at [high] school"

Other / Unspecified sources

  • "I was researching the current state of wikis for a paper I'm supposed to get ready in a few days and Citizentium popped up several times"
  • "while researching a new chemistry project"
  • "a number of different places both in print media and online".
  • "through the media"
  • "in an editorial on Wikipedia"
  • "I think I heard about Citizendium in the newspaper, but I think I rediscovered it whilst online."
  • "I heard about Citizendium from a guest speaker on a meeting".
  • "I have been made aware of the existence of this project during a lecture at my company."


Citizendium Moderator Group
Professionalism | Moderator Blocking Procedures | Article Deletion Policy
Application Review Procedure | Moderator Policy | Help for Moderators

|width=10% align=center style="background:#F5F5F5"|  |}