Talk:Kilmer Middle School: Difference between revisions
imported>Larry Sanger No edit summary |
imported>Chris day |
||
| Line 3: | Line 3: | ||
Here is a perfect test case for my own principles regarding article "feasibility." It seems to me that if we can have an article about Kilmer Middle School, we need to be able to have articles about ''every'' Middle School in the U.S., and equivalent schools in other English-speaking countries (at least!). And we need to be able to keep all such articles ''current'' (so the teacher lists don't go out of date) and otherwise of reasonably high quality. | Here is a perfect test case for my own principles regarding article "feasibility." It seems to me that if we can have an article about Kilmer Middle School, we need to be able to have articles about ''every'' Middle School in the U.S., and equivalent schools in other English-speaking countries (at least!). And we need to be able to keep all such articles ''current'' (so the teacher lists don't go out of date) and otherwise of reasonably high quality. | ||
Will that be possible anytime in the next, say, few years? How is Wikipedia doing in this regard? We can take that as an indication for CZ. | Will that be possible anytime in the next, say, few years? How is Wikipedia doing in this regard? We can take that as an indication for CZ. --[[User:Larry Sanger|Larry Sanger]] 01:32, 30 November 2006 (CST) | ||
This article would not survive in this format even in wikipedia. In general lists such as faculty should be heavily discouraged since they will be outdated so soon and they are mostly unnotable people. I think a google search and the school district pages will always be a better resource. We only need articles on the | |||
Revision as of 02:37, 30 November 2006
Feasibility
Here is a perfect test case for my own principles regarding article "feasibility." It seems to me that if we can have an article about Kilmer Middle School, we need to be able to have articles about every Middle School in the U.S., and equivalent schools in other English-speaking countries (at least!). And we need to be able to keep all such articles current (so the teacher lists don't go out of date) and otherwise of reasonably high quality.
Will that be possible anytime in the next, say, few years? How is Wikipedia doing in this regard? We can take that as an indication for CZ. --Larry Sanger 01:32, 30 November 2006 (CST)
This article would not survive in this format even in wikipedia. In general lists such as faculty should be heavily discouraged since they will be outdated so soon and they are mostly unnotable people. I think a google search and the school district pages will always be a better resource. We only need articles on the